Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

56 Minn. 351

Allen v. McIntyre

Supreme Court of Minnesota

Decided January 30, 1894

Supreme Court of Minnesota · decided 1894-01-30

Appeal by plaintiffs, John H. Allen and Daniel H. Moon, from an order of the District Court of Eamsey County, James J. Egan, J., made September 18, 1893, setting aside a judgment entered December 1, 1891, against the defendant Charles W. McIntyre for $863.12.

Relies on Crosby v. Farmer · Jensen v. Crevier

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1894-01-30

How this case has been cited

Cited by 6 later decisions — most recently March 1938

6 state decisions

2018941900191019201930decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Mitchell, J.

¶1This is an appeal from an order setting aside a default judgment on the ground that the summons had never been served on the defendant.

¶2The proof of service was the affidavit of one Belknap that he served the summons and complaint, personally, on the defendant, in the city of St. Paul, on November 9, 1891. It is settled that the proof of service, even when consisting of the return of an officer, is not conclusive, as against direct proceedings in the action to set aside the judgment. Crosby v. Farmer, 39 Minn. 305, (40 N. W. 71.)

¶3But such proof should ordinarily be upheld, unless opposed by clear and satisfactory evidence. Jensen v. Crevier, 33 Minn. 372, *352(23 N. W. 541.) It would be dangerous practice to permit tbe return or affidavit made at the time to be overcome by tbe mere uncorroborated affidavit, made long afterwards, upon slippery memory, of tbe defendant, to tbe effect that no service was ever made upon bim. But tbis record does not, as plaintiffs seem to suppose, present such a case. It is a significant fact that although tbe judgment was obtained in November, 1891, and defendant was and continued a resident of tbe same city as tbe plaintiffs, and was actually engaged in business, and regularly, or at least frequently, buying large quantities of goods from plaintiffs, and frequently in their place of business, — not less than six times within a month after this action is alleged to have been commenced, — yet it does not appear that during all that time they ever spoke to bim about tbe matter, or attempted to collect their judgment, until August, 1893; and no explanation of tbis course of conduct is attempted to be given.

¶4It is also to be noted that plaintiffs offered no evidence in rebuttal, except tbe affidavit of tbe party who claimed to have made tbe service, in substantially tbe same terms as bis original affidavit on tbe summons, and without any reference to tbe particular place where, or tbe circumstances under which, be claimed to have made tbe service. Tbe affidavit of tbe deputy sheriff to whom tbe execution was delivered in August, 1893, is of little or no importance.

¶5Tbe delay of tbe defendant in moving to set aside tbe judgment is explained by bis affidavit that be was not aware that any action bad been commenced until shortly before be made tbis motion.

¶6Upon tbe whole record, we could not say that the court was not justified in setting tbe judgment aside.

¶7Order affirmed.

¶8(Opinion published 57 N. W. Rep. 1060.)

/56/minn/351 · .json · Public domain