Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

568 P.2d 357

State v. Lloyd

Utah Supreme Court

Decided August 10, 1977

Utah Supreme Court · decided 1977-08-10

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently October 1990

2 state decisions

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“(1) Any person who exercises unauthorized control over a vehicle, not his own, without the consent of the owner or lawful custodian and with the intent to temporarily deprive the owner or lawful custodian of possession of the vehicle, is guilty of a class A misdemeanor. (2) An offense under this section is a third degree felony if the actor does not return the vehicle to the owner or lawful custodian within 24 hours after the exercise of unauthorized control.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including State v. Basford

Relies on Beck v. State · Gaskin v. State · 23 Utah 2d 14 - State v. Ash

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1977-08-10

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

ELLETT, Chief Justice

¶1(dissenting).

¶2In order for one crime to be included in another crime, there must not be any elements in the lesser that were not also in the greater.1 The law is stated in 7 Am.Jur.2d., Automobiles and Highway Traffic, Section 343 as follows:

. . . Furthermore, since the offense of taking and using á motor vehicle without the consent of its owner is distinct in its elements from the offense of larceny, an acquittal of one of these offenses is not a bar to a prosecution for the other.

¶3The reason for this is that there is an element in depriving an owner which is not required for the crime of larceny. The crime of larceny is set out in our statute thus:

A person commits theft if he obtains or exercises unauthorized control over the property2 of another with a purpose to deprive him thereof.

¶4The crime of depriving an owner of his automobile is defined in our statute as follows:

Any person who drives a vehicle, not his own, without the consent of the own- . er thereof and with intent temporarily to deprive said owner of his possession of such vehicle, without intent to steal the same is guilty of a misdemeanor. . . 3 [Emphasis added.]

¶5It is obvious that there is an element in the crime of depriving an owner that is not required in the crime of larceny, to wit: the defendant must drive the car, which in larceny he need not do. In larceny, the defendant may push the motor vehicle, he may dismantle it, or he may load it on a truck and haul it away. One may steal a motor vehicle that cannot be started, but in order to deprive a owner of the use of his car, the defendant must drive it.

¶6The law of depriving was enacted to serve as a deterrent to the propensity of young people to take a joy ride in an automobile that they did not own, without having to charge them with the felony of stealing the car when they were apprehended. Therefore, “driving” was intentionally made an element of the crime.

¶7In the case of State v. Ash4 this Court said:

In the instant case the jury found the defendant guilty of intending to deprive the owner permanently of the use of his car, and we cannot see why they should *360also have been required to decide if he only intended to deprive the owner temporarily. The two crimes are based upon contrary intentions in the mind of the defendant. However, this does not mean that one offense is necessarily included within the charge made of the other. An acquittal of one is not a bar to a prosecution for the other offense.
[Emphasis added.]

¶8Whether or not the court can find a defendant guilty of an included offense after he has found the defendant not guilty of the greater matter is not in this case for the reason that depriving an owner of the use of his motor vehicle is not an included offense in the crime of larceny with which appellant was charged and acquitted. The state may file a complaint for depriving an owner if it chooses to do so.

¶9I would reverse the judgment of conviction.

¶10. Beck v. State, 238 Ind. 210, 149 N.E.2d 695, 697 (1958); State v. Matthews, 295 A.2d 745, 747 (Del.Super.1972); Gaskin v. State, 244 Ark. 541, 426 S.W.2d 407, 409 (1968).

¶11. 76-6-404, U.C.A.1953 as amended (1975 Supp.).

¶12. 41-1-109, U.C.A.1953 as amended.

¶13. 23 Utah 2d 14, 456 P.2d 154 (1969).

/568/p2d/357 · .json · Public domain