Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

57 How. Pr. 322

Morris v. Hiler

New York Court of Common Pleas

Decided June 15, 1879

New York Court of Common Pleas · decided 1879-06-15

<p> .Secemer—when application by judgment creditors to compel‘the payment over of moneys in his hands will not be granted,—hi3 liability for false </p> <p>Upon an application by the judgment creditors to compel the receiver to pay over the moneys in his hands, to the credit of their judgments, where it appears that the receiver, as such, has been made liable, through the conduct of his attorney, to an action, at the instance of the defendant, in an action brought in the receiver’s name, the court will not order the funds tobe paid over to the judgment creditors.</p>

Decided 1879-06-15

J. F. Daly, J.—

¶1The “ Stilwell act ” proceedings under which Dusenbury was arrested were ostensibly brought by the receiver, but were really instituted in his name by the attorneys for the judgment creditors acting as the receiver’s attorneys and for the benefit of the fund.

¶2Under such circumstances the receiver would not probably be personally liable; but for the acts of his attorney and agents would be liable as receiver, and the fund in court be subject to the claim of the injured party (Camp agt. Barney, 4 Hun, 373: Cardot agt. Barney, 63 N. Y., 281).

¶3*324I think it reasonable that any recovery of damages for false ■imprisonment in such a case should be payable out of the fund. The “ Stilwell proceedings ” were instituted to benefit and increase the fund and to satisfy the judgment creditors’ ■claim. An injury, such as false imprisonment inflicted by proceedings taken in the name of the receiver, may be the ■subject of an action against the attorneys or other persons ■directly responsible for it; but while there is a fund out of which it may be satisfied there is no good reason for turning over ■the injured party to the chances of individual responsibility.

¶4The parties prosecuting proceedings under the Stilwell act are not required to give an undertaking against damages, as in the case of arrests under the Code, and the defendant, if unlawfully imprisoned, must have recourse to an action against ■the persons causing the imprisonment. If a receiver is the ostensible party liable the court should, in ordinary cases, provide for the satisfaction of the injured party out of the fund. Motion for distribution of fund denied.

/57/howpr/322 · .json · Public domain