Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

57 How. Pr. 324

Egan v. Thomson

New York Court of Common Pleas

Decided November 15, 1878

New York Court of Common Pleas · decided 1878-11-15

<p>Appeal "from judgment entered upon an order of Mr. justice Robinson, dismissing the plaintiff’s complaint, at trial term, upon the ground: First. That the defendant’s offer was made to William Haw, Jr., and that no one else could enforce it; and, second, that the offer was void for the want of consideration.</p> <p>The following is a copy of the agreement sued on:</p> <p>“ New Yoek, Motfr. 3d, 1877.</p> <p>Wm. Haw, Jb., Esq.:</p> <p>My Deab Sir. — I will contribute the expense of boxes for Benj. Beyea, candidate for assembly, twenty-first district, not to exceed three dollars per district; on presentation of bill at my office, check will be paid.</p> <p>Yours, very truly.</p> <p>JAMES F. THOMSON.”</p>

Decided 1878-11-15

Van Hoesen, J. —

¶1Thomson’s letter to Haw shows clearly that Thomson expected Haw to procure the boxes and to induce some carpenter to build them by promising that the boxes would be paid for when the bill for them was presented at Thomson’s office.

¶2If Haw was not to order the boxes, why did Thomsom refer to the presentation of a bill for them at his office ?

¶3If Thomson intended merely to send to Haw a contribution towards the expense of Beyea’s canvass, there would have been no propriety in his saying any thing concerning the bill.

¶4A request from Thomson to Haw to contract for the boxes and a promise by Thomson to pay not more than three dollars per district for the boxes furnished, appearing on the face of the letter, or being naturally implied by its terms, I think Haw had power to employ a carpenter to build the boxes, and that any carpenter, hired by Haw, who built the boxes, relying upon the promise contained in the letter, had the right to look to Thomson for his pay. It appears that the letter was handed by Haw to Egan, who then went on and finished the boxes.

¶5Ho question is made respecting the delivery. I think the plaintiff, upon the evidence, made out a case, which, within the decisions hereinafter cited, entitled him to a verdict (Trustees of Hamilton College agt. Stewart, 1 N. Y., 581; Barnes agt. Perrine, 12 N. Y., 18; Van Rensselaer agt. Aiken, 44 N. Y., 126).

¶6The judgment should be reversed, a new trial ordered, with costs to abide event.

¶7Daly, O. J., concurred.

¶8Judgment reversed.

/57/howpr/324 · .json · Public domain