Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

57 Utah 553

Summit County v. Rich County

Utah Supreme Court

Decided January 19, 1921

Utah Supreme Court · decided 1921-01-19

<p>1. Pleading — Demurrer Admits Facts Pleaded. A demurrer to the complaint admits facts pleaded therein.</p> <p>2. Constitutional Daw — Every Reasonable Dotjbt Solved in Favor of Constitutionality of Statute. Before the court can declare an act of the Legislature unconstitutional, it is its duty to solve every reasonable doubt in favor of the act.</p> <p>3. Counties — Complaint Help to Show Unconstitutional Attempt of Legislature to Define Boundary Line Between Counties. The complaint in an action between counties held to sufficiently allege that Sess. Laws 1917, c. 113, passed pursuant to Comp. Laws 1907, § 487, attempting to define the boundary line between Summit and Rich counties, is in violation of Const, art. 11, § 3, which provides that no territory shall he stricken from any county except upon a vote of a majority of the voters in such territory as well as of the county to which it is annexed.1</p> <p>4. Counties — Legislature in Fixing Disputed Boundary Line Must Follow the Statutory Description as Nearly as Possible. In defining the boundary, line between two counties, where there is a dispute, it is the duty of the Legislature, under Comp. Laws 1907, § 487, to follow the statutory description as nearly as practicable; and, if it finds it impracticable to follow it as to some particular point,' then to establish a new line, hut the fact that some parts of the boundary line may be ambiguous and unascertainable by engineering skill does not justify it in ignoring altogether that which is clear and unmistakable, ’in view of Const, art. 11, § 3.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently December 1929

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Eevebsed and remaNded, with /directions · Decided 1921-01-19

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1On Rehearing.

THURMAN, J.

¶2On application for rehearing respondent *564expresses the fear that tbe opinion -of the court may be construed as holding, unqualifiedly, that the legislative act, ch. 113, Laws Utah 1917, is unconstitutional.

¶3The court is of the opinion that the language used, considered as a whole, is not susceptible of such construction. The sufficiency of the complaint was all that was before the court and the court only intended to hold that the complaint showed the act to be unconstitutional. With this explanation the application for rehearing is denied.

CORFMAN, C. J., and WEBER, GIDEON, and FRICK, JJ., concur.
/57/utah/553 · .json · Public domain