Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

57 W. Va. 80

Bosworth v. Wilson

West Virginia Supreme Court

Decided January 31, 1905

West Virginia Supreme Court · decided 1905-01-31

Bill by A. S. Bosworth and another against W. G. Wilson and others. From an order sustaining a demurrer to the bill, complainants appeal. Dismissed.

Relies on Hannah v. Bank · Gillespie v. Coleman · Greer v. Mitchell

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1905-01-31

How this case has been cited

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently March 1964

3 state decisions

101905191019201930194019501960decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

BRAnnon, President.

¶1To a bill in equity in the circuit court of Randolph county filed by Boswortli and Rum'barger against Wilson and others a demurrer was entered, and the court made an order which sustained the demurrer and gave leave to file a second amended bill.

¶2From this order an appeal has been taken.

¶3This Court cannot consider the merits. The law gives it no jurisdiction of an appeal from such a decree, for want of finality. The order is interlocutory. The court can retract it and make an opposite ruling. An order merely sustaining a demurrer, but not dismissing the bill, is not appealable. It is a mere opinion not carried out. Gillespie v. Colemam 98 Va. 276; 2 Ency. Pl. & Prac. 114; 2 Cyc. 605. The case, of White v. C. & O. R. Co., 26 W. Va. 800, rules this case.. It holds that an order sustaining a demurrer and giving leave to amend a declaration is not appealable.

¶4Even if the feature of leave to amend were absent, and it were only an order sustaining a demurrer, no appeal would lie; but that feature makes it plainer that the order is not final. 2 Cyc. 605; 601; 2 Ency. Pl. & Prac. 114. See Hannah v. Bank, 53 W. Va. 82.

¶5The case of Gillispie v. Coleman, supra,holds that there is no appeal whether the order sustains or overrules a demurrer. Parsons v. Snyder, 42 W. Va. 511, holds that an order overruling a demurrer will not support an appeal.

¶6We dismiss the appeal as improvidently granted.

¶7Dismissed.

/57/wva/80 · .json · Public domain