Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

58 Ala. 202

Nunn v. Norris

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided December 15, 1877

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1877-12-15

Heard before Hon. Charles Turner. The appellees, Sarah Norris and others, heirs at law and distributees of James Moss, deceased, filed this bill against Lamar, administrator of Moss, and Nunn and others, seeking, among other things, to enforce a vendor’s lien on certain lands which the administrator had sold and conveyed to Nunn, The case was as follows: Lamar obtained an order of the probate court to sell the lands for one third -cash, and the balance to be paid in one and…

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently December 1891

2 state decisions

Relies on Butler v. O'Brien · Pickens v. Yarborough · Williamson's Adm'r v. Ross

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1877-12-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

BRICKELL, C. J.

¶1We may concede that Lamar’s acceptance of bis own debt, in part payment of the purchase money of the lands, was unauthorized; and that it rested in the election of the appellees, either to treat it as a payment, and hold him liable for it, or, to disregard it, and hold Nunn liable for an amount of the purchase money, equal to the debt. It may be conceded further, that if they elected to disregard it as a payment, the appellees would have had a lien on the lands for an amount of the purchase money equal to it, which a court of equity would have enforced. The appellees were thus clothed with inconsistent rights, and were bound to elect which they would exercise. Lamar, as administrator, could be charged only on the ground that the acceptance of his own debt, was a payment of the purchase money. It would result from charging him, that there would be no right of recovery against Nunn; for that right depends on the ground, that the purchase money has not been paid. It does not appear to have been controverted by evidence, (though, the bill avers the contrary) that on the final settlement of Lamar’s administration in the court of probate, the appellees, with full knowledge of the facts, caused, or suffered him, to be charged with the entire purchase. money of the lands, thus increasing the amount of the decrees they obtained against him. Having thus elected to treat the purchase money as paid, and obtained decrees against Lamar for it, they cannot now assert it is unpaid, and' proceed against Nunn for its recovery. They have elected the right they would exercise, and must abide the election. — Butler v. O’Brien, 5 Ala. 316; Pickens v. Yarborough, 30 Ala. 408; Williamson v. Ross, 33 Ala. 509.

¶2The decree of the chancellor must be reversed, and a decree is here rendered dismissing the bill, at the costs of the appellees in this court, and in the Court of Chancery.

/58/ala/202 · .json · Public domain