Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

58 Cal. 262

People v. Mortier

California Supreme Court

Decided July 1, 1881

California Supreme Court · decided 1881-07-01

<p>Appeal from a judgment of conviction and an order denying anew trial in the Superior Court of Mendocino County. McGarvey, J.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1881-07-01

How this case has been cited

Cited by 24 later decisions — most recently February 2011

22 state decisions

4018811890190019101920193019401950196019701980199020002010decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Sharpstein, J., dissenting:

¶1I dissent. The record shows that when charging the jury the Court said: “I will try to give you what I consider the law applicable to this case. In the first place, in order to save the reporter the trouble of taking down all I may read, I would state that I propose to read from the Penal Code §§ 187,188,189,190, 192, 194, ¿95,196,197,198,1096, and 1097. If counsel on either side desire that any other sections of the code shall be read, they will suggest it.” (The Court then read the sections of the Penal Code above mentioned.)

¶2The contents of the sections referred to are not given.

¶3The Penal Code (§ 1093) provides that, “ If the charge be not given in writing, it must be taken down by the phonographic reporter.”

¶4It is quite true that writing includes printing, but the numerals which we find in the record do not include any written or printed matter. They refer to a book outside of the record in which may be found something that the Court read to the jury.

¶5*270The object of the provision which requires that the charge, if not in writing, shall be taken down by the phonographic reporter, doubtless is to have a complete and reliable record of all that the Judge says in his charge to the jury. In this case the reporter states that the Court read twelve sections of the Penal Code, the contents of which nowhere appear in the record. It seems to me that this constitutes error, for which the judgment and order should be reversed.

¶6'McKee, J., and McKinstry, J., concurred in the opinion of Sharpstein, J.

/58/cal/262 · .json · Public domain