Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

58 Cal. 279

Williams v. Montgomery

California Supreme Court

Decided July 1, 1881

California Supreme Court · decided 1881-07-01

Denson, J. The evidence in the case was in effect as follows: W. S. Williams, one of the firm plaintiff, after proving the execution of two chattel mortgages by E. S. Johnson (afterwards introduced in evidence), testified as follows: The defendant, Montgomery, requested us to advance to E. S. Johnson the sum of one thousand dollars, in order to enable the said E. S. Johnson to buy out the interest of his brother, John Johnson, in the said growing crop.

Decided 1881-07-01

The Court :

¶1This action was brought to recover the sum of five hundred dollars, alleged to have been paid by plaintiffs to and for the use and benefit of defendant, at his special instance and request. Trial by jury, and verdict for three hundred and fourteen dollars.

¶2We have examined the transcript very carefully, and find no evidence therein to sustain the verdict. If the mortgages referred to were in any manner connected with plaintiffs’ claim, it appears from the evidence that plaintiffs received a quantity of wheat, sufficient in value to pay the indebtedness of the defendant to them. But in no view of the case is there sufficient evidence to sustain the finding of the jury.

¶3Judgment and order reversed.

/58/cal/279 · .json · Public domain