Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

58 N.H. 182

Sargent v. Putnam

Supreme Court of New Hampshire

Decided August 5, 1877

Supreme Court of New Hampshire · decided 1877-08-05

Assumpsit, on the common counts, and a special count on a written contract. The plaintiff’s specification, containing two hundred and thirteen items, amounted to more than $35,000. Sixty-four of the items, specially disputed, amounted to more than $7,000. The defendant’s set-off, containing one hundred items, amounted to more than $50,000.

Relies on Copp v. Henniker · Perkins v. Scott

Decided 1877-08-05

Doe, C. J.

¶1 Section 2 of chapter 35, Laws of 1876, authorizes the court to commit to one or more referees any cause at law or equity, or the determination of any question of fact “wherein the parties are not, as matter of right, entitled to a trial by jury.” “As matter of right” here means as matter of constitutional right. And, by the constitution, neither party is entitled to a jury trial for the settlement of accounts too complicated to be intelligently investigated and adjusted in that way. Copp v. Henniker, 55 N. H. 179, 210, 211; Perkins v. Scott, 57 N. H. 55, 81, 82, 83, 84; Bellows v. Bellows, ante, p. 60.

¶2 Exception overruled.

Bingham, J., did not sit.
/58/nh/182 · .json · Public domain