Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

58 Vt. 558

Lombard v. Batchelder

Supreme Court of Vermont

Decided May 15, 1886

Supreme Court of Vermont · decided 1886-05-15

Trespass for assault and battery. Trial by jury, September Term, 1885, Powers, J., presiding. Verdict for the plaintiff to recover $425 damages. Held: in exemplary damages, if he (the master) is without malice, however evil the motive of the servant may have been. Hagan v. Railroad Co. 3 R. I.' 88; Wardrobe v. Stage Co. 7 Cal. 118; The Amiable Nancy, 3 Wheat. 546, 558; Railroad v. Finney, 10 Wis. 388; Cleghorn v. Railroad Co. 56 N. Y. 44.

Relies on The Amiable Nancy · Cleghorn v. . N.Y. Cen. H. River R.R. Co.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1886-05-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 4 later decisions (1 by the Supreme Court) — most recently April 1983

3 state decisions

1018861890190019101920193019401950196019701980decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The opinion of the court was delivered by

Rowell, J.

¶2The only question made in argument is, whether exemplary damages are recoverable against husband and wife in an action against them for the malicious trespass of the wife, the husband being free from improper motive or other blame in the premises.

¶3When two persons have so conducted themselves as to be jointly liable for a tort, each is responsible for the injury *560committed by their common act. But when motive may be taken into consideration, the improper motive of one cannot be made the ground of aggravating the damages against the other if he is free from such motive. In such case the plaintiff must elect against which party he will seek aggravated damages. Clark v. Newsam, 1 Exch. 131.

¶4So a master, sued for the trespass of his servant, is not liable for 'exemplary damages, however evil the motive of the servant, if he is himself without malice. The Amiable Nancy, 3 Wheat. 546; Cleghorn v. The N. Y. Central & Hudson River R. R. Co. 56 N. Y. 44.

¶5In all these cases it is to be observed that the plaintiff has his election to proceed against all or any of the wrong-doers; and as in such case it would be unjust to make the malicious motive of one party the ground of enhancing damages against another who is free from such motive, if the plaintiff proceeds against all, he thereby deprives himself' of the right he otherwise would have had to claim exemplary damages.

¶6But the case is different when suit is brought for a tort of the wife for which the husband is liable solely by reason of her coverture, for then the plaintiff has no election, but must proceed against both; and herein lies the distinction between this case and the cases relied upon by the defendant; for the husband is liable, not as master, but as husband, and because of the oneness of the twain in the eye of the law. We have not been referred to, nor have we found, much authority for this distinction, but we think it exists on principle.

¶7Judgment affirmed.

/58/vt/558 · .json · Public domain