Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

59 Wash. 529

In re Rainey

Washington Supreme Court

Decided August 6, 1910

Washington Supreme Court · decided 1910-08-06

<p>Application filed in the supreme court August 5, 1910, for a writ of habeas corpus.</p>

Denied · Decided 1910-08-06

Per Curiam.

¶1This is a proceeding by habeas corpus. It appears that the petitioner is charged with the crime of assault in the second degree. His bail bond was fixed in the sum of $5,000, which he alleges is an excessive and unreasonable amount, and that he is unable to give the same. The assault appears to have been made without provocation and was an atrocious one, and the person assaulted was and is severely injured. The maximum penalty for this offense is imprisonment in the penitentiary for a period of not more *530than ten years or by a fine of not more than $1,000, or by both. Rem. & Bal. Code, § 2414. In view of this punishment and of the atrocity of the offense, of which the court fixing the amount of the bail appears to have been advised, we are of the opinion that the bail is not so unreasonable or excessive in amount as to warrant a reduction.

¶2The writ is therefore denied.

Rudkin, C. J.

¶3(dissenting) — The amount of bail to be exacted depends upon the circumstances of each case and necessarily rests to a large extent in the discretion of the court or committing magistrate, but I am nevertheless of opinion that bail in the sum of five thousand dollars for a laboring man accused of a common felony, where he has no means except his daily wages, is grossly excessive and should' be materially reduced. I therefore dissent.

/59/wash/529 · .json · Public domain