Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

6 Ky. Op. 710

Commonwealth v. McDaniel

Court of Appeals of Kentucky

Decided June 5, 1873

Court of Appeals of Kentucky · decided 1873-06-05

<p>APPEAL PROM LEWIS CIRCUIT COURT.</p>

Decided 1873-06-05

¶1Opinion by

Judge Lindsay:

¶2The indictment charges the commission of but one offense, The unlawful taking and conveying away of one lot of hay.

¶3The fact that defendants were engaged, or are charged to have been engaged on three different days in the commission of the offense did not render it necessary that the commonwealth shall treat the act or acts committed on each day as a separate and distinct taking and conveying away. It is charged that one lot of hay was taken. The. talcing and carrying away of one thing can constitute but one offense, although the wrong-doers may have occupied themselves two, three, or five days in the perpetration of the wrong.

¶4There are offenses which m'ay be constituted by a succession of acts performed at different times. When these are set out in the indictment there may be more days than one mentioned in which the successive acts were done. Bishop’s Crim. Procedure, Sec. 244. In this case but one lot of hay was taken and carried away. It is charged in effect that a portion was taken and carried away on the 10th, another portion' on the 11th and the remainder on the 15th of February, 1870. The succession of acts performed on these three several days constitute together the one offense. That of taking' and carrying away the lot of hay specifically described as having been taken under execution by Appleton, the constable, and placed by him in the possession of bailee Rea.

¶5Possibly the commonwealth might have treated each removal of *711a cart or wagon load, as a separate taking, but it was not bound to do so. Neither is it required to treat the taking on each day as an act separate and distinct from' taking on the next or any other subsequent day.

Phister, for appellant.Halbert, for appellees.

¶6The judgment dismissing the prosecution is reversed, and the cause remanded with instructions, to overrule the demurrer and for further proceedings.

/6/kyop/710 · .json · Public domain