Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

6 Mass. 398

Lowell v. Spring

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1810-05-15

<p>Upon a complaint to the Comraoh Pleas by the owner of lands overflowed by a mill-dam, against the nwaer of the dam, the latter may traverse the complainant’s title to the leads overflowed; may set up a right to overflow them, without payment of damages, or for an agreed composition; or he may deny that he is owner uf the dam, or that the complainant has sustained any damage if issue be joined upon either point, an appeal lies to this Court — Otherwise, where the quantum of the damages is the only question.</p> <p>No appeal lies to this Court, by stat 1782, c. 11, except in civil suits commenced by writ</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1810-05-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently September 1926

5 state decisions

20181018201830184018501860187018801890190019101920decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Parsons, C. J.

¶1On examining the record in this case, and the *326statutes relating to processes of this kind, it appears to us that the appeal cannot be sustained. Upon a complaint originally preferred by the owner of lands overflowed by a mill-dam, against the owner of the dam, the respondent may defend himself by traversing the complainant’s title to the lands overflowed; or he may set up a right to overflow them, without payment of damages, or for an agreed composition; or he may deny that he is the owner of the dam, or that the complainant has sustained any damages.

S. Hubhard for the complainant. King, for the respondent.

¶2If an issue be joined upon either of these points of defence, it shall be tried by a jury at the bar of the Common Pleas, subject to a right in either party to appeal to this Court. If, on the appeal, a verdict be found for the complainant, a certificate in the nature ol a procedendo shall go to the Common Pleas ; on which v£-t*399 ] that court shall proceed to * direct the sheriff to sum-^x mon and impanel a jury' to assess the damages demanded m ike complaitfL,

¶3But when the quantum of' "damages, either on the original complaint or on a new complaint, is the question between the parties,— there being no defence by the respondent against the payment of some damages, — on either of the groundihtforesaid, no appeal lies to this Court from any order or judgment of the 'Common Pleas. If that Court proceed illegally, the remedy for the party aggrieved is by certiorari issued by this Court. (1)

¶4It has probably been supposed by the parties, that the'statute of 1782, c. 11, creating the Court of Common Pleas, and giving an appeal to this Court to any party aggrieved, extends to the case before us. But the original jurisdiction there given to the Common Pleas is of civil suits commenced by writ, and is not extended to proceedings founded on complaint, authorized by particular statutes, which do not give any appellate jurisdiction to this Court.

¶5 Let the appeal he dismissed.

¶6 Vide Stat. 1785, c. 74, and 1797, c. 63. — 3 Mass Rep 184, Vandusen vs. Comstock, in Error.

/6/mass/398 · .json · Public domain