Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

6 Sandf. 673

Dolan v. Petty

The Superior Court of New York City

Decided October 31, 1851

The Superior Court of New York City · decided 1851-10-31

Complaint for work, labor, and services, in making certain militia uniforms at seventeen dollars each-. The answer traversed the plaintiff’s claim as stated, and then set forth that the clothes made were not worth more than twelve dollars each.

Decided 1851-10-31

Sandfokd, J.,

¶1with the concurrence of all the justices, denied the motion. He said, the court will not make an order under the last clause of subdivision fifth of section 244 of the code as amended in July, 1851, unless the answer clearly admit a specific amount to be due. Here the defendants do not distinctly admit any sum to be due. They deny the claim made, which was for an agreed price, and say the work was not worth more than a less price named. We feel impelled'to be strict and guarded in making orders under this stringent remedy.

¶2As to the writ of inquiry, the court has no authority to send an issue of fact to be tried by a sheriff’s jury. (Code, § 252.)

/6/sandf/673 · .json · Public domain