Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

6 S.C. Eq. 486

Trescott v. Smyth

Court of Appeals of South Carolina · decided 1826-07-01

This was a rule on the Master, taken out by consent of parties, to shew cause why he should not pay six rent due by the defendant, J. Smyth, to Mrs Christie, Executrix of Alexander Christie, on the 16th of February 1826, and for which rent she distrained on the 1st of April 1826 on a negro named Molly. It was agreed that the Master should sell the wench and hold the proceeds of the sale to abide the order of the Court.

Decided 1826-07-01

¶1Cueia, per

Colcocic, J.

¶2The Court unanimously con*489cur with the presiding Chancellor, that the negro was not liable to the distress for rent. The case is certainly within the spirit if not the letter of the act of 1799, which was intended to restrain the rigour of the common law on this subject. The act declares that no slave shall be liable to be distrained or shall at any time be distrained for house rent or any other rent, unless such slave shall bona fide belong to such person or persons as may be lawfully liable to or chargeable with the rent. 1 Brev. 242. Now it cannot be said that this negro was bona fide the property of Mr Smyth; she was mortgaged to Mr Grimke. The time of payment had been passed for years. The only interest then which Mr Smyth could have in her was an equitable interest, which' .certainly was not a subject of distress. It would seem to me a work of supererogation to refer to many authorities on this point, when there are two or three of our own in which it is expressly decided that a mortgagee after the day of payment is considered as the owner of the property. In the case of Wolfe v. O'Farrell, 1 Const. Rep. Tread. 151, although the paper in that case was a bill of sale by way of mortgage, the general doctrine is expressly recognized by all the Judges. And so in the case of Payne v. Renshaw, 1 Harp. Rep. 275. The motion therefore is refused.

An equitable Jhís'n^écfof distress,

¶3Decree affirmed.

/6/sceq/486 · .json · Public domain