Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

6 Thomp. & Cook 335

Nichols v. Hill

New York Supreme Court

Decided February 15, 1875

New York Supreme Court · decided 1875-02-15

APPEAL by defendants Iremonger, from a judgment in favor of plaintiff, entered upon the report of a referee. The action was brought by John A. Nichols against Charles A. Hill and others, to foreclose a mortgage given by defendant Hill. The defendants Iremonger, subsequent to the execution of such mortgage, filed a mechanics’ lien for work done upon buildings on the mortgaged premises.

Decided 1875-02-15

Barnard, P. J.

¶1In the case of Knickerbocker Life Insurance Co. v. Hill, ante, page 285, argued at the same time with’ this case, I arrived at the conclusion that the defendants, the Iremongers *336by virtue of the referee’s deed to Kuhn, and by the declaration of trust from Kuhn to them became the owners of the legal estate subject to whatever power in trust, if any, was created by the declaration in trust, In this respect that case is identical with this. The Iremongers were, therefore, entitled to destroy, if they could, any prior lien affecting their land.

¶2They sought to show that the mortgage in question, was given for no present consideration; that nothing had ever been given therefor as between the original parties, and that the plaintiff paid nothing for it. The referee erred in excluding this evidence.

¶3There should be a new trial at special term, costs to abide event.

¶4Jv,dgment reversed and new trial granted.

/6/thompcook/335 · .json · Public domain