Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

6 Vt. 119

Ambler v. Bradley

Supreme Court of Vermont

Decided January 15, 1834

Supreme Court of Vermont · decided 1834-01-15

This was an action on book. Exception was taken, to the auditor’s report, with respect to two items only of the plaintiff’s account. With respect to the first, the objection was, that the plaintiff had given a credit on the charge, which had not expired at the bringing of the suit, but had expired at the time of the audit. As to this, the defendant insisted, that it could not legally be allowed.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1834-01-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 10 later decisions — most recently April 1895

10 state decisions

401834184018501860187018801890decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1*120The opinion of the court was pronounced by

Phelps, J.

¶2— Upon the first point raised in this case, it is unnecessary to inquire what would be. the effect of the objection, were the item in question the only charge against the defendant. In this case the parties had a running account exclusive of the disputed item, and other claims existed at the commencement of the suit, proper to be litigated. Supposing then that the term of credit had not expired when the suit was brought, but had expired at the time of the audit, should it be taken into the account?

¶3The statute (Rev. Laws, p. 143) is peremptory, and requires the auditor to adjust the account, up to the time of the audit. This item being then due, the auditor should have included it, notwithstanding that the credit had not expired at the commencement of the suit. This provision of the statute is in conformity with the common law. In actions of account, the account is always adjusted up to the time of taking it. This results from the object of the suit, which is to ascertain and recover the balance due. There would certainly be no propriety in making a false balance, to be rectified by an after suit, of in giving judgment against a party notin arrear. Besides, the adjustment of the account is in the nature of the assessment of damages, where interest, payments, &c. are adjusted to the time of judgment.

¶4As to the other point, the objection is ill-founded in fact. The plaintiff and Wells were never partners in the business of the mill. — They never shared in profit and loss. The share which Wells received was a mere compensation for his labor. This point has been often determined.

¶5But admitting that plaintiff and Wells were joint creditors of the defendant, it was still competent for the parties to sever the claim. It seems they did so by mutual consent; and the payment to Wells of his share completed the severance. After this, Wells had no interest in the residue; but it. was due to the plaintiff alone. The authorities cited by the counsel abundantly support this position.

¶6The judgment of the county court is reversed, and judgment rendered for the plaintiff.

/6/vt/119 · .json · Public domain