Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

60 Miss. 323

Watkins v. State

Mississippi Supreme Court

Decided October 15, 1882

Mississippi Supreme Court · decided 1882-10-15

Hon. J. W. Buchanan, Judge. This indictment for grand larceny charged the appellant with stealing a cow, the property of George Valerius Young; and the appellant pleaded not guilty. The material incidents of the trial are stated in the opinion of the court. 1. To constitute larceny, not only the conversion but also the taking must be felonious. 2 East P. C. 694; 2 Arch. Grim. Pr. 1184.

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“[I]t is manifest from the language of the statute that the Legislature intended to deny the judge the power of originating independent instructions of its own motion, not called for or rendered necessary by those requested by counsel.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including 274 So. 2d 658 - Sexton v. State

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1882-10-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 15 later decisions — most recently August 1975

15 state decisions

501882189019001910192019301940195019601970decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Chalmers, J.,

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2The bill of exceptions recited that the presiding judge in the court below, of his own motion, prepared a written instruction which, in the presence of the jury and against the protests of the defendant, he handed to the district attorney and this officer at once passed it back to the judge with the request that it might be given in charge to the jury; which was forthwith done.

¶3To this action of the judge, in thus volunteering instructions in the interest of the State the defendant excepted. Our statute (Code 1880, sect. 1740) permits the modification by the judge of the written instructions asked by either party, and this power of modification may undoubtedly be exercised as well by giving a wholly new instruction, supplementary and amendatory of those asked, pointing out the limitations *325and qualifications on the doctrines announced, as by annexing the qualifying words to those asked.

¶4We are not disposed to hamper and abridge the court in the exercise of this valuable power, nor to prescribe too strictly the shape which the modification must take; but it is manifest from the language of the statute that the Legislature intended to deny the judge the power of originating independent instructions of its own motion, not called for or rendered necessary by those requested by counsel.

¶5The instruction prepared by the judge in this case was not in modification or explanation of those asked on either side, and evidently was not so regarded by him, else he would not have resorted to the expedient of handing it to the representative of the State in order that a request might be preferred by that officer in connection with it:

¶6Clearly that which the statute intends to forbid cannot be rendered admissible by so idle a ceremony as this. The judge having no right to prepare and give it of his own motion, did not acquire auy by the course adopted.

¶7The second instruction given for the State informed the jury that if the accused sold property which he knew did not belong to him, and appropriated the proceeds to his own use, they should find him guilty of larceny. This was erroneous in two aspects. It was not claimed that the accused thought that the animal alleged to be stolen belonged to him, but that he sold it under the belief that it was the property of his wife. Neither is it necessarily true that selling property which the seller knows does not belong to him, is larceny. Under some circumstances it might amount only to a breach of trust, and under others to obtaining money under false pretences. A felonious taking is essential to larceny, and a sale might take place where there had been no such taking.

¶8Reversed and new trial.

/60/miss/323 · .json · Public domain