Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

60 Tex. 167

Barbee v. Stinnett

Texas Supreme Court

Decided October 16, 1883

Texas Supreme Court · decided 1883-10-16

<p>Error from Hamilton. Tried below before the Hon. T. L. Nugent.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently December 1927

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1883-10-16

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

West, Associate Justice.

¶1This is a second suit between the same parties. The object of each suit was the same. The title of each in both suits was admitted to be good. The evidence disclosed, and it was in fact practically conceded on all hands, that the only question in dispute was as to the true boundary line between the parties.

¶2The character of this action, in which the title of each party is admitted, and the suit has no other object than merely to determine the division line between them, has been passed on and determined by this court.

¶3In Spence v. McGowan, 53 Tex., 30, it was held that in such a case, where the question was, as in this case, not one of title, but of boundary alone, the plaintiff was not, under the statute then in force (but now repealed), entitled to his second action.

¶4In the case of Corporation of San Patricio v. Mathis, 58 Tex., 242, for reasons there stated, it was deemed best, without opening the question for re-argument, to follow the decision made in Spence v. McGowan. The case of Bird v. Montgomery, 34 Tex., 713, though not authority (Taylor v. Murphy, 50 Tex., 295; Peck v. San Antonio, 51 Tex., 490), may be consulted on the subject.

¶5It is due to the able and learned judge who presided at the trial of this case in the district court to state that it was tried before the decision in Spence v. McGowan was made known, that opinion being delivered at the Galveston term, 1880.

¶6The judgment below will be reversed and judgment here rendered for the plaintiff in error.

¶7Reversed and rendered.

¶8[Opinion delivered October 16, 1883.]

/60/tex/167 · .json · Public domain