Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

600 So. 2d 978

Ex Parte Besselaar

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided March 20, 1992

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1992-03-20

Cited by 18 later decisions — most recently January 2005

17 state decisions

Relies on 598 So. 2d 895 - Ex Parte Jackson

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1992-03-20

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1

¶2The petitioner, Tracey H. Besselaar, filed a Rule 32, A.R.Cr.P. (formerly Temporary Rule 20), petition for relief. The circuit court denied the petition, holding that the issue presented could have been raised at trial and, additionally, that the issue could have been raised on direct appeal. The Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed. This Court granted Besselaar's petition for the writ of certiorari.

¶3In his petition to this Court, Besselaar argues that he is entitled to relief because, he says, his trial counsel was ineffective; specifically, he bases this allegation on a claim that his attorney advised him to plead guilty to an indictment that was barred by the statute of limitations. Besselaar argues that, on advice of counsel, he pleaded guilty to a 1989 indictment that was based upon the theft of a motor vehicle in 1983.

¶4We do not require that a claim of ineffective assistance of counsel be raised either in the trial court or on direct appeal when the defendant is represented by the same counsel at trial and on appeal. See Ex parte Jackson, 598 So.2d 895 (Ala. 1992).* Besselaar was represented by the same counsel at trial and on appeal; therefore, review of his claim of ineffective assistance of counsel is available now through Rule 32, A.R.Cr.P.

¶5We note from the record that the trial court apparently interpreted the petition as raising only the issue of whether the defense of the statute of limitations was waived by the guilty plea; therefore, the trial court did not address the issue of whether trial counsel had been effective. This may have been due to the fact that Besselaar's trial counsel also represented him at the Rule 32 hearing.

¶6The petition on its face appears to have merit; therefore, we reverse the Court of Criminal Appeals' affirmance of the trial court's denial of relief and instruct the Court of Criminal Appeals to remand this case for an evidentiary hearing to determine whether Besselaar received effective assistance of counsel.

¶7REVERSED AND REMANDED WITH INSTRUCTIONS.

¶8HORNSBY, C.J., and MADDOX, SHORES, ADAMS, HOUSTON, STEAGALL, and KENNEDY, JJ., concur.

¶9ALMON, J., concurs in the result.

¶10

* Reporter of Decisions Note:

¶11The opinion in Ex Parte Jackson was originally released on Feb. 28, 1992; the present opinion cited the original opinion in Jackson. The Jackson opinion was withdrawn and a new opinion issued on May 8, 1992; the citation given here is that for the substituted opinion in Jackson, which was not materially different from the original opinion in regard to the point for which it was cited.

*980

/600/so2d/978 · .json · Public domain