Culbertson v. Mernitz’s Empirical Analysis
1992
Citation profile
3 federal appellate · 19 state decisions
How this case has been cited
Cited by 23 later decisions — most recently August 2018
3 federal appellate · 19 state decisions
Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.
Relationships
Relies on Gregory v. United States · Reavis v. Antinore · Phelps Dodge Corp. v. AFL-CIO Joint Negotiating Committee · 8 Cal. 3d 229 - Cobbs v. Grant · Schloendorff v. Society of the New York Hospital
Most-quoted passages
The sentences later courts lift from this opinion, ranked by how many decisions quote each — the parts of the opinion doing the work. These counts are smaller than the citation total above because most of the 23 citing decisions cite the case generally; a passage count includes only decisions quoting that exact language verbatim.
““The patient’s right of self-decision can be effectively exercised only if the patient possesses enough information to enable an intelligent choice. The patient should make his own determination on treatment. The physician’s obligation is to present the medical facts accurately to the patient ... and to make recommendations for management in accordance with good medical practice ... Informed consent is a basic social policy for which exceptions are permitted (1) where the patient is unconscious or otherwise incapable of consenting and harm from failure to treat is imminent; or (2) when risk-disclosure poses such a serious psychological threat of detriment to the patient as to be medically contraindicated. Social policy does not accept the paternalistic view that the physician may remain silent because divulgence might prompt the patient to forego needed therapy. Rational, informed patients should not be expected to act uniformly, even under similar circumstances, in agreeing to or refusing treatment.””
3 later decisions quote this exact passage“Resolution of the issue of the necessity of expert medical testimony in informed consent cases depends on whether the issue is viewed through the eyes of the physician or the patient. When viewed through the eyes of the physician, it is easy to see that a physician should not be required to guess or speculate as to what a hypothetical “reasonably prudent patient” would “need to know” in order to make a determination. A physician should only be required to do that which he is trained to do, namely, conduct himself as a reasonably prudent physician in taking a history, performing a physical examination, ¡ordering appropriate tests, reaching a diagnosis,- prescribing a course of treatment, and in discussing with the patient • the medical facts óf the proposed procedure, including the risks inherent in either accepting or rejecting the proposed course ■ of treatment. From a physician’s viewpoint, he should not be called upon to be a “mind reader” with the ability' to peer into the brain of a prudent patient to determine what such patient “needs to know,” but should simply be called upon to discuss medical facts and recommendations with the patient as a reasonably prudent physician would.”
1 later decision quote this exact passage“Emphasizing respect for patient autonomy, we acknowledged that liberty interests protected in the Indiana Constitution and public policy values preserved -in Indiana, statutory and common law reflect “a commitment to patient self-determination.” In seeming disregard of these fundamental principles, however, today’s decision rejects the prudent patient standard in informed consent cases. It ignores “the basic human need of self-determination and individual autonomy” in deference to decision-making by physicians. The central concern of the majority appears to be whether a plaiqtiff should be permitted to establish an informed consent claim without presenting expert medical testimony. This issue should not blind the Court to the basic values articulated in Lawrance. Nor-does the prudent patient standard eliminate the need for a plaintiff to present medical expertise.”
1 later decision quote this exact passage · from the dissent
How this case has been treated — in progress
Whether each later court followed, distinguished, criticized, or overruled this decision. The treatment classification (task #35) runs highest-cited cases first and lights up here as it reaches this one.