61 Cal. 363
Decided August 30, 1882
California Supreme Court · decided 1882-08-30
judgment for the plaintiff, and from an order denying a new trial, in the Superior Court of the County-of San Diego. McNealy, J. The facts are stated in the syllabus.'
Relies on Truman v. Robinson
Decided 1882-08-30
¶1Upon the authority of Truman v. Robinson, 44 Cal. 623, and Branson v. Caruthers, 49 id. 374, the judgment and order are affirmed.
¶2I dissent: In my judgment the case in hand does not belong to the class of cases covered by Truman v. Robinson and Branson v. Caruthers.