Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

61 Mich. 233

Drew v. Claypool

Michigan Supreme Court

Decided April 29, 1886

Michigan Supreme Court · decided 1886-04-29

<p>Circuit court attachment — Return of writ without personal service — Premature if made prior to return-day — Judgment not supported, thereby.</p> <p>A circuit court writ of attachment was returned three days before the return-day, without personal service on the defendant, who was published in and a judgment rendered against him.</p> <p>Held, that the return was premature, and the judgment must be reversed.</p>

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently July 1922

3 state decisions

Relies on Norberg v. Heineman · Hitchcock v. Hahn

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Eeversed · Decided 1886-04-29

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Campbell, C. J.

¶1In this case judgment by default was entered under a writ of attachment returnable April'T, 1885, and returned “Not found,” April4, 1885.

¶2*234It is assigned as error that this return was premature, and not good in support of the judgment. This has been so often decided that no discussion is needed.1

¶3The judgment must be reversed, with costs of both courts.

The other Justices concurred.

¶4A justice of the peace has power, under the statute of amendments, to permit an officer to amend his return to a writ of attachment by showing when, it was in fact made and the writ and return filed with the justice. Kidd v. Dougherty, 59 Mich. 210 (head-note 2).

¶5A sheriff, in his return to a writ of attachment issued January 18 and returnable February 5, certified to the seizure of property on the teste day, and that he was unable to find the defendant, and returned and filed the writ and return on the return-day.

¶6Held, that the return was not premature; that the certificate of his inability to find the defendant had no reference to the date of the seizure, but took effect from the date of filing. Hitchcock v. Hahn, 60 Mich. 459 (head-note 1).

/61/mich/233 · .json · Public domain