Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

61 Mich. 275

Donlin v. McQuade

Michigan Supreme Court

Decided April 29, 1886

Michigan Supreme Court · decided 1886-04-29

<p>'Skating rink — Proprietor who-receives skates from Ms patrons, giving check therefor, is liable as a bailee for the property — Failure to deliver the skates on demand of bai’or and surrender of check, on the ground of his inability io find them, is a conversion for which trover will lie for their value.</p> <p>EPlaintifi left his skates with the agent of defendant in charge of his skating rink on the last night of the season, receiving a check therefor, as on former occasions, and as was the custom with patrons of the rink. He afterwards demanded the skates of defendant, presenting ■his check, and was informed that they were not there, but that he could have them if they were. Plaintiff then demanded their value, and defendant caused a search to be made, and claimed not to be able to find them.</p> <p>Held, in an action of trover for the value of the skates, that the defendant was bailee of the property, and under the circumstances it -was his duty to preserve and deliver it to the owner on demand and presentation of the check given therefor; that his failure to do so for the reason given was a sufficient conversion to sustain trover for ■its value.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Reversed · Decided 1886-04-29

How this case has been cited

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently June 1932

5 state decisions

20188618901900191019201930decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Champlin, J.

¶1Plaintiff brought trover against defendant, and showed that, in 1884, the defendant was the proprietor of the Detroit Roller Skating Rink, and on the last night the defendant’s'rink was open for the season of 1884, plaintiff left his skates with defendant by delivering them to Mr. McConnell, whom defendant had in charge of the skating-room at his rink, and received from him a check for said skates, as was done on previous occasions, and as was the custom with patrons of the rink; that he thereafter went and demanded his skates from the defendant, and presented his check therefor ; that defendant stated that he did not have them, — that the skates were not there and he could not give them to him, ■but he could have them if they were there; afterwards plaintiff demanded the value of the skates, and defendant said they were not there; that defendant caused search to be made for the skates, and afterwards said he had not got them, because he could not find them.

¶2After proving the value of the skates plaintiff rested.

¶3Defendant testified in his own behalf that he recollected •the plaintiff calling on him for the skates; that he looked over all the skates he had, and Mr. Donlin’s were not among them.; that he knew Mr. Donlin’s skates, as they had Donlin’s name stamped on them, and so told Dqnlin they were not there, — that if they were, Donlin could have them.

¶4Upon this testimony the circuit judge directed a verdict for the defendant.

¶5*278This was error.

¶6The defendant was bailee of the property, and under the-circumstances it was his duty to preserve the property, and deliver it to the bailor on presentation of tire check and demand therefor. His neglect to do so, simply for the reason that he could not find it, was a conversion for which the action of trover will lie.

¶7The judgment must be reversed, and a new trial ordered..

The other Justices concurred.
/61/mich/275 · .json · Public domain