Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

61 Wis. 3

Prince v. McCarty

Wisconsin Supreme Court

Decided September 23, 1884

Wisconsin Supreme Court · decided 1884-09-23

<p>Special proceeding— Compelling delivery of bóoles and papers of public officer — Appealable order.</p> <p>The term “special proceedings,” in subd. 2, sec. 3069, R. S., is used as defined in secs. 2593-96. A proceeding under ch. 43, R. S., to compel the delivery of books and papers of a public officer to his successor, being before a judge and not in the court, is not such a special proceeding, and the order made therein is not appealable.</p>

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently January 1907

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1884-09-23

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Lyon, J.

¶1The respondent was county clerk of Ashland county. The board of supervisors of that county assumed to remove him from such office, and appointed the appellant in his place. The respondent refused to deliver to the appellant the books and papers pertaining to the office, and the latter instituted proceedings before the circuit judge under ch. 43, R. S., to compel him to do so. The judge denied the relief sought. This is an appeal by Prince from the order of the judge in that behalf. The respondent now moves to dismiss the appeal.

¶2This is a special statutory proceeding before the circuit judge, upon whom the statute confers powers not conferred by the common law. It is not a proceeding at chambers which the court may review, for the statute confers no authority upon the court in respect to it. It is not, therefore, a special proceeding under R. S., 713, secs. 2593-2596, because it is not a proceeding in the court (sec. 2593), and hence an order made therein is not appealable under sec. 3069, subd. 2. The term “ special proceedings ” is used in that section as defined in the other sections above cited, and does not include proceedings to compel delivery of official books and papers under ch. 43. The appellant has mistaken his remedy.

¶3By the Court.— Appeal dismissed.

/61/wis/3 · .json · Public domain