Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

623 F.2d 252

Docket No. 1180, Docket 80-7145.

Elsmere Music, Inc. v. National Broadcasting Co.

Second Circuit Court of Appeals

Argued May 28, 1980. Decided June 9, 1980.

Second Circuit Court of Appeals · decided 1980-06-09

2 counsel of record

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“[T]he concept of “conjuring up” an original came into the copyright law not as a limitation on how much of an original may be used, but as a recognition that a parody frequently needs to be more than a fleeting evocation of an original in order to make its humorous point. A parody is entitled at least to “conjure up” the original.”

quoted by 8 later decisions, including Fisher v. Dees, Tin Pan Apple, Inc. v. Miller Brewing Co., Inc.

“[I]n today's world of often unrelieved solemnity,”

quoted by 3 later decisions, including MCA, Inc. v. Wilson, L.L. Bean, Inc. v. Drake Publishers, Inc.

Relies on 482 F. Supp. 741 - Elsmere Music, Inc. v. National Broadcasting Co. · Columbia Pictures Corp. v. National Broadcasting Co.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Opinion by Per Curiam · Decided 1980-06-09

How this case has been cited

Cited by 73 later decisions (1 by the Supreme Court) — most recently September 2021 · most notably Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music, Inc. (1994), Warner Bros Inc Ag Dc v. American Broadcasting Companies Inc J (1983)

33 federal appellate · 2 district · 2 state decisions

35019801990200020102020decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Paul Siegert, New York City (Siegert & Miller, Philip R. Kaufman, New York City, on the brief), for plaintiff-appellant.

Pamela G. Ostrager, New York City (Coudert Brothers, Carleton G. Eldridge, Jr., R. David Jacobs, Corydon B. Dunham, Gen. Counsel, Jay E. Gerber, William T. Abbott, N. B. C., New York City, on the brief), for defendant-appellee.

Before FEINBERG, NEWMAN and KEARSE, Circuit Judges.

PER CURIAM:

¶1

This copyright infringement suit concerns a skit, shown on the television program "Saturday Night Live," poking fun at New York City's public relations campaign and its theme song. In the four-minute skit the town fathers of Sodom discuss a plan to improve their city's image. The satire ends with the singing of "I Love Sodom" to the tune of "I Love New York." The District Court for the Southern District of New York (Gerard L. Goettel, Judge) rejected appellant's claim of copyright infringement, concluding that the parody was protected fair use. Believing that, in today's world of often unrelieved solemnity, copyright law should be hospitable to the humor of parody, and that the District Court correctly applied the doctrine of fair use, we affirm on Judge Goettel's thorough opinion.1 482 F.Supp. 741.

1

The District Court concluded, among other things, that the parody did not make more extensive use of appellant's song than was necessary to "conjure up" the original. 482 F.Supp. at 747. While we agree with this conclusion, we note that the concept of "conjuring up" an original came into the copyright law not as a limitation on how much of an original may be used, but as a recognition that a parody frequently needs to be more than a fleeting evocation of an original in order to make its humorous point. Columbia Pictures Corp. v. National Broadcasting Co., 137 F.Supp. 348, 354 (S.D.Cal.1955). A parody is entitled at least to "conjure up" the original. Even more extensive use would still be fair use, provided the parody builds upon the original, using the original as a known element of modern culture and contributing something new for humorous effect or commentary

/623/f2d/252 · .json · Public domain