Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

63 Cal. 397

Jennings v. Le Roy

California Supreme Court

Decided May 11, 1883

California Supreme Court · decided 1883-05-11

The action was brought to collect an assessment upon lots fronting on Bay Street, in the city and county of San Francisco, for grading that street under the act of the legislature passed April 1, 1878, entitled “ an act to authorize the board of supervisors of the city and county of San Francisco to order Bay Street graded, and to change its grade.” Section one of the act authorized and empowered the board of supervisors of the city and county of San Francisco to order…

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1883-05-11

How this case has been cited

Cited by 7 later decisions — most recently September 1901

7 state decisions

40188318901900decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Myrick, J.

¶1The Act of April 1, 1878 (Stats. 1877-78, p. 931), must be construed as having the effect of changing the *401grade of Bay Street at the points therein designated, and of authorizing that street, between the termini named, to be graded to the line of grade thereby established, without a petition from property owners. At the time of the passage of that act there was no constitutional objection to its passage. It was competent' for the legislature to pass the act, even though it might, in effect, repeal or modify some provisions.of existing laws, and that without re-enacting the statutes as modified or changed. The purpose of the act is sufficiently stated in its title. The respondent claims that when the line of grade has once been established (the street not being in fact graded to the line), the adjacent property owners have a right of property in the line of grade as established which cannot be taken from them without compensation. We have not been referred to any case or to any' text writer which sustains the proposition. The cases are uniform, that the owner holds his property subject to the right of the legislative authority to establish and change grades; some cases, however, have stated that the owner is entitled to damages if his improvements or his right to use them are affected. The case before us is not such a one.

¶2The court found that the resolution ordering the work to be done was not, after its introduction, published before final action thereon; that notice of the nature and character of the work to be done, with specifications, was not posted in the office of the superintendent of streets; and that no notice of the award was published. The only evidence upon that subject was the assessment, diagram, warrant, and affidavit of demand and non-payment, with the indorsements thereon showing due recording. The statute (Stats. 1871—72, p. 815, § 12) makes the warrant, assessment, and diagram prima fade evidence of the regularity and correctness of the assessment, and of the prior proceedings and acts of the superintendent, and of the regularity of all the acts and proceedings of the board of supervisors, upon which they are based; therefore there was some evidence of the regularity and correctness of the proceedings, and, there being no evidence in conflict, the findings above referred to are not sustained.

¶3We are of opinion that the general statutes concerning the improvement of streets in the city and county of San. Fran*402cisco, as modified by the Act of April 1, 1878, apply to the case before us.

¶4The judgment and order are reversed, and the cause is remanded for a new trial.

¶5Thornton, J., and Sharpstein, J., concurred.

¶6Hearing in Bank denied.

/63/cal/397 · .json · Public domain