Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

64 Neb. 369

Morgan v. State

Nebraska Supreme Court

Decided April 2, 1902

Nebraska Supreme Court · decided 1902-04-02

<p>1. License: Billiard and Pool: Village: Ordinance. Under the provisions of section 46, and subdivision 12 of section 69, article 1, chapter 14, Compthed Statutes, 1901, village authorities have ample power by ordinance to license and regulate billiard and pool rooms.</p> <p>2. -: -: License Tax. And by subdivision 8 of section 69, aforesaid, village trustees are authorized to raise general revenue by levying and collecting a license tax on persons engaged in the business of conducting billiard and pool rooms.</p> <p>3. Ordinance:. Title. An ordinance whose main object is to license and regulate a business or calling is not wholly void because a provision imposing a small occupation tax is not clearly expressed in its title, as required by section 79 of article 1, chapter 14, Compthed Statutes, 1901.</p>

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““The interests of peace, good order and public morality require that the billiard and pool room should be conducted according to such rules and standards, and subject to such restrictions, as may be prescribed by the municipal authorities. Such a room is not, we concede, per se a nuisance, but without regulation and supervision it is likely to become so anywhere, and in a village it is apt to degenerate into a trysting-place for idlers and a nidus for vice.””

quoted by 1 later decision, including State ex rel. McMonies v. McMonies

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Affirmed · Decided 1902-04-02

How this case has been cited

Cited by 10 later decisions — most recently May 1939

10 state decisions

301902191019201930decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Sullivan, C. J.

¶1These cases were submitted together on the same briefs, and will be disposed of in one opinion. In each case the defendant, Morgan, was convicted of violating a village ordinance, which was clearly intended to regulate and tax the business of keeping a pool and billard room. Under the stipulation of the parties, the validity of the ordinance is the only question properly before us for decision. The first contention of the defendant is that the village authorities in the adoption of the ordinance, attempted to exercise a power which the legislature had not conferred upon them. This contention can not be sustained. The power exercised by the board of trustees is, we think, fairly within the provisions of section 46, and subdivision 12 of section 69, article 1, chapter 14, Compthed Statutes, 1901. *370The interests of peace, good order and public morality require that the billiard and pool room should be conducted according to such rules and standards, and subject to such restrictions, as may be prescribed by the municipal authorities. Such a room is not, we concede, per se a nuisance, but without regulation and supervision it is likely to become so anywhere, and in a village it is apt to degenerate into a trysting-place for idlers and a nidus for vice.

¶2But it is insisted that, if the ordinance was an authorized exercise of the police power, the provision imposing an occupation tax, in addition to the license fee, is invalid. Without conceding this proposition, which, on account of the restrictive title of the ordinance, is not free from doubt, we dispose of it by holding that, under the rule established by numerous decisions of this court, the taxing clause may be stricken out without destroying, or affecting in any way, the regulative provisions of the ordinance. Scott v. Flowers, 61 Nebr., 620; State v. Stuht, 52 Nebr., 209. See, also, East Kingston v. Towle, 48 N. H.; 57; Chicago, B. & Q. R. Co. v. Jones, 149 Ill., 361; McPherson v. Blacker, 92 Mich., 377; Grimes v. Eddy, 126 Mo., 168.

¶3The judgment in each case is

¶4Affirmed.

/64/neb/369 · .json · Public domain