Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

64 N.H. 353

10 A 701

Chadbourne v. Gilman

Supreme Court of New Hampshire

Decided June 5, 1887

Supreme Court of New Hampshire · decided 1887-06-05

Bill in Equity, to set aside a mortgage of certain land made by Israel H. Gilman to his wife, Mary E. Gilman, in June, 1885, to secure a promissory note from him to her for $2,225. Facts found by the court. The plaintiffs are creditors of I. H. Gilman, and in July, 1885, caused the mortgaged premises to be attached on a writ against him, and now seek to hold the same discharged of the mortgage for the satisfaction of their debt.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently March 1921

1 state decisions

Relies on Jones v. Clifton · Hunt v. . Johnson · Shepard v. Shepard

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1887-06-05

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Blodgett, J.

¶1 At common law a wife cannot be the immediate grantee of her husband, but she may take an estate from him through the intervention of a trustee. In equity, however, it is otherwise, and a direct conveyance from husband to wife will be *354 upheld whenever there is an adequate consideration. Shepard v. Shepard, 7 Johns. Ch. 57; Arundell v. Phipps, 10 Ves. 146, 149; Hunt v. Johnson, 44 N. Y. 27; Dale v. Lincoln, 62 Ill. 22; Sims v. Rickets, 35 Ind. 181; Smith v. Dean, 15 Neb. 432; Jordan v. White, 38 Mich. 253; Putnam v. Bicknell, 18 Wis. 351; Beard v. Dedolph, 29 Wis. 136; Fenelon v. Hogoboom, 31 Wis. 172; (Car penter v. Tatro, 36 Wis. 297 ; Mc Campbell v. Mc Campbell, 2 Lea 661; Sayers v. Wall, 26 Grat. 354; Powe v. McLeod, 76 Ala. 418; Washburn v. Gardner, 76 Ala. 597; Craig v. Chandler, 6 Col. 543; 2 Sto. Eq. Jur. (12th ed.) ss. 1368, 1372-1375, and notes;— and see, also, Wallingsford v. Allen, 10 Pet. 583, and Jones v. Clifton, 101 U. S. 225. This rule or principle of equity jurisprudence has not been abrogated in this state by statute (G. L., c. 183, s. 13); and as it is found as a fact that the mortgage deed sought to be annulled was given and taken in good faith, and as it must be deemed to have been upon an adequate consideration (Cooper v. Alger, 51 N. H. 172, Kaufman v. Whitney, 50 Miss. 103, Rowland v. Plummer, 50 Ala. 182), the plaintiffs make no ease for equitable relief. Exceptions sustained.

¶2 Bill dismissed.

Allen, J., did not sit: the others concurred.
/64/nh/353 · .json · Public domain