Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

65 Ala. 586

Adams v. Robinson

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided December 15, 1880

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1880-12-15

Tried before the Hon. James Q. Smith. This action was brought by Mrs. Margaret Bobinson, a married woman, against James B. Adams, and was commenced on the 19th September, 1877.

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“It is always competent for a witness to state that he had a conversation with a third person, on a certain subject germane to the issue in dispute, and at a time specified, as a reason for his accurate recollection of a fact to which he has testified.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including 333 So. 2d 902 - Crowe v. State

“(w)here ... an agent violates his positive instructions given him by a principal, this would constitute gross negligence, which would render him liable for such loss or damage as may be occasioned by his misconduct.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including Wood v. Old Security Life Insurance

Relies on Myers v. Gilbert · Bagby v. Harris

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1880-12-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 15 later decisions — most recently September 1989

1 federal appellate · 14 state decisions

2018801890190019101920193019401950196019701980decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

SOMEBVILLE, J.

¶1— The complaint in this case alleges a valid contract between the plaintiff and the defendant, the violation by the defendant of a duty growing out of, and imposed on him by it, and a loss consequent thereon. Its averments were, therefore, sufficient, certainly to entitle the plaintiff to the recoverv of nominal charges. — Code (1876), | 2978. If the defendant rented out the plaintiff’s storehouse, contrary to her instructions, a right of action arose *591immediately, in favor of the latter, against the former. The principle is well settled, that when one contracts to do an act for another, and either does it unskillfully, or fails to do it at all, an action in the case will lie against him, to recover such loss or damage as may result from his negligence, carelessness, or want of skill, in the discharge of the duties imposed on him by the contract. Myers v. Gilbert, 18 Ala. 467.

¶2Every wrong imports a damage, and when none other is proved, and the evidence shows a clear breach of duty, nominal damages are always recoverable.— Bagby v. Harris, 9 Ala. 178; Sedgwick on Dam., 6th ed., 461 [337].

¶3Where, furthermore, an agent violates his positive instructions given him by a principal, this would constitute gross negligence, which would render him liable for such loss or damage as may be occasioned by his misconduct; and, on a principle well recognized in many cases of tort, every doubtful circumstance would be construed unfavorably to the rights and interests of the agent thus perpetrating the wrong. Story on Agency, § 333 ; Dodge v. Tileston, 12 Pick. 333-4.

¶4It is always competent for a witness to state that he had a conversation with a third person, on a certain subject germane to the issue in dispute, and at a time specified, as a reason for his accurate recollection of a fact to which he has testified. The rules of evidence are those of common sense and human experience ; and both of these teach us, that the retentiveness of a witness’ memory, as to a particular fact or incident, is greatly improved where, after seeing or hearing of it, he subsequently converses about it. The fact of plaintiff’s conversation with Moses was relevant evidence, therefore ; but the narration of the details of it were properly excluded by the Circuit Court.

¶5The demurrer to the complaint was also properly overruled, and the other rulings of the court, when tested by the above principles of law, were free from error.

¶6The judgment is affirmed.

/65/ala/586 · .json · Public domain