Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

65 Ga. 698

Dawson v. Pennaman

Supreme Court of Georgia

Decided September 15, 1880

Supreme Court of Georgia · decided 1880-09-15

Fraud. Title. Warranty. Actions. Trover. Before Judge LAWSON.' Putnam County. At Chambers. January 27th, 1880. Pennaman brought trover for a mule against Dawson in a justice'court. On the trial, the evidence in his behalf was, in brief, as follows: Plaintiff went to a livery stable where defendant had his mules and horses for sale, for the purpose of effecting a trade or swap with him. Plaintiff told defendant that he wanted a good family horse.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1880-09-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 9 later decisions — most recently July 1970

9 state decisions

201880189019001910192019301940195019601970decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Jackson, Chief Justice.

¶1This case came before the superior court on a writ of certiorari, and the superior court having sustained the certiorari and remanded the case for another hearing in the justice court, the plaintiff in error excepted and, assigns for error the judgment sustaining the certiorari. The suit was for a mule, wherein plaintiff in the justice court was non-suited on the ground that his testimony was insufficient prima facie to make a case to go to the jury. It seems that the horse was warranted to be sound, and the justice held that the action should have been upon the breach of warranty, and not in trover for the mule; but the evidence is to the effect that the plaintiff below was cheated and defrauded badly out of the mule, and hence no title passed under the-Code, and the repeated *700rulings of this court, and therefore the superior court was right in sustaining the certiorari, and awarding a new trial in the justice court. Code, §§2633, 2751, 3178.

¶2Unquestionably the fraud which, under section 2633, voids a sale, and consequently does not permit title to pass, must be actual fraud, mixed with deceit and corrup. tion, and not merely legal or constructive fraud ; but in this case there is evidence to show such actual fraud, and the proper tribunal should have passed upon it, and the plaintiff should not have been non-suited. It is true that if there had ' been a warranty unmixed with such actual fraud, the plaintiff’s remedy would have been a suit on the breach of that warranty; but where there is actual fraud, so that no title passed, he had his remedy or his choice of remedies, either to sue for the property, the title to which never passed from him, or on the breach of warranty for damages. The superior court was right, therefore, to sustain the certiorari, and remand the cause for another hearing on the merits.

¶3Judgment affirmed.

/65/ga/698 · .json · Public domain