Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

65 Ill. 398

Hurlbert v. Ellenberg

Illinois Supreme Court

Decided September 15, 1872

Illinois Supreme Court · decided 1872-09-15

<p>Appeal from the Circuit Court of Iroquois county; the Hon. Charles H. Wood, Judge, presiding.</p>

Relies on Christopher v. Ballinger

Decided 1872-09-15

Mr. Justice Scott

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court:

¶2There is but a single question presented by this record, viz: Was the demurrer properly sustained to the plea in bar of the action ?

¶3It is averred in the plea that, since the continuance of this suit, at the ¡November term, 1871, to wit: at the March term, 1872, there was another suit pending, on the chancery side of the court, for the same cause of action—the note in controversy having been secured by a mortgage—that appellant, by his attorney, made an agreement with the attorney of appellee that if appellant would allow a decree on the mortgage, at the March term of the court, he would dismiss this suit; and it is further averred that appellant did permit appellee to take a decree against the land at that term of the court, wherefore he avers that the suit ought to be dismissed, and . concludes with a verification and prayer for judgment.

¶4The plea, by its beginning and conclusion, purports to be a plea in bar, and in form and substance is such; and when the facts stated are admitted, as they are by the demurrer, to be true, they constitute no defense to the action.

¶5It was held by this court, in Christopher v. Ballinger, 47 Ill.

¶6107, that an agreement between parties that upon compliance with certain conditions the suit should be dismissed, and noncompliance therewith, could not be pleaded in bar of the action; and the decision in that case is conclusive of the one at bar.

¶7The judgment is affirmed.

¶8Judgment affirmed.

/65/ill/398 · .json · Public domain