¶1dissenting.
¶2I dissent for the same reason that the majority acknowledges that the “[cjircum-stantial evidence in this case also permits an inference that the plaintiff suffered no injury.” Even if the defense expert testified that the plaintiff may have been in need of some temporary medical treatment after the accident, the jury was presented with other evidence that the accident did not cause the plaintiff any injuries. The majority concedes that were we to apply “the same rationale as was used in Jordan
¶3The majority concedes that there was no record basis to support the trial court’s conclusion that the evidence was ‘undisputed’ that an injury occurred. In fact, there was conflicting evidence on the issue of whether the plaintiff suffered any injury from the accident. “By failing to recognize the jury’s prerogative to reject the expert testimony on causation, particularly in light of the lay testimony which conflicted with the expert testimony, the trial court erred in concluding that the manifest weight of the evidence was contrary to the jury verdict.” Id. at 1110 (citation omitted).
¶4The jury resolved the conflicts in the evidence and I would let the verdict stand.
¶5. Jordan v. Brown, 855 So.2d 231 (Fla. 1st DCA 2003).
¶6. Schmidt v. Van, 65 So.3d 1105 (Fla. 1st DCA 2011).