Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

66 Mass. 483

Barlow v. Leavitt

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided November 15, 1853

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1853-11-15

The declaration in this case contained two counts, one against the defendant for refusing to accept a bill of exchange or draft drawn on him, payable to the plaintiff, by one J. W„ Andrew, -for $51.28, the defendant having sufficient funds in his hands, belonging to said Andrew, wherewith to meet said draft.

Decided 1853-11-15

Bigelow, J.

¶1There is no ground for the motion to dismiss this action. The court below had jurisdiction both of the subject-matter and of the parties. The defect, if any existed, was in the misjoinder of two separate and distinct causes of action, for each of which the law prescribes different remedies. At common law, the only proper mode of taking advantage of such a defect was by a demurrer or motion in arrest of judgment. 1 Chit. Plead. 236. Under the practice act, St 1852, c. 312, §§ 17, 21, 22, it can be done only by demurrer.

¶2Motion to dismiss overruled.

/66/mass/483 · .json · Public domain