Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

67 Conn. 255

Chapin v. Babcock

Supreme Court of Connecticut

Decided February 7, 1896

Supreme Court of Connecticut · decided 1896-02-07

Action in the nature of trespass de bonis, brought originally before a justice of the peace, and thence by the defendant’s appeal to the Court of Common Pleas in Hartford County, where the case was tried to the jury, before Walsh, J., and verdict and judgment rendered for the defendant, from which the plaintiff appealed for alleged errors in the rulings and charge of the court. The case is sufficiently stated in the opinion.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Error, and judgment set aside · Decided 1896-02-07

How this case has been cited

Cited by 17 later decisions — most recently July 1993

17 state decisions

4018961900191019201930194019501960197019801990decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Andrews, C. J.

¶1This case was originally brought before a justice of the peace. The complaint alleged a cause of action in the nature of trespass quare clausum fregit and the carrying away of goods. Irene R. Babcock and James H. Babcock were named as defendants. The justice rendered judgment against both. From that judgment Irene R. Babcock appealed to the Court of Common Pleas in Hartford county. James H. Babcock did not appeal. In the Court of Common Pleas, Irene R. pleaded only the general issue. A trial was had thereon to the jury, and a verdict was given in her favor. The plaintiff now has appealed to this court.

¶2Upon the trial to the jury the plaintiff claimed and asked the court to hold, that the appeal by Irene R. Babcock vacated the justice judgment as to both herself and James H. Babcock. The court did not so rule, but instructed the jury that the appeal by Irene R. vacated the said judgment only as against herself; and that the said justice judgment remained in force as against the said James H. Babcock. We think this ruling was correct.

¶3A judgment against several persons in an action of tort is severable. The liability of tort feasors is several as well as joint; as well after judgment as it is before a suit is brought. Freeman on Judgments, § 236; Morgan v. Chester, 4 Conn., 387; Sheldon v. Kibbe, 3 id., 214; Atwater v. Tupper, 45 id., 144. Of course the satisfaction of such a judgment by any one of those against whom it was rendered, would be a discharge as to all.

¶4The Court of Common Pleas held also that the plaintiff must prove, in order to recover, that the acts for which damages were claimed were such as both Irene R. Babcock and James H. Babcock were jointly liable for. This was error. In the Court of Common Pleas the case stood as though Irene R. was the only defendant named in the com*257plaint, or as though it had not been served on James H. Clearly she would be liable for any trespass, several or joint, upon the premises, or to the property named in the complaint, committed by her, and any such trespass might be proved against her. 1 Swift’s Dig., 532.

¶5It is urged that a new trial ought not to be granted because the damages will be small. Small damages, however, and nominal damages, do not mean the same thing. Where there is a real right involved the damages, even if very small, are substantial and not nominal. To deprive a party of these, by refusing him a new trial because they must be small, would be to do him a great injustice. Michael v. Curtis, 60 Conn., 363, 369.

¶6There is error and the judgment is set aside.

¶7In this opinion the other judges concurred.

/67/conn/255 · .json · Public domain