Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

67 Mass. 486

Commonwealth v. Madden

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided September 15, 1854

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1854-09-15

Indictment charging the defendant with being a common seller of intoxicating liquors. At the trial in the court of common pleas, before Byington, J. the district attorney offered ^ evidence, to show that, during a part of the time covered by the indictment, the defendant kept a public house, and had upon it an innkeeper’s sign. The defendant objected to the admission of the evidence as irrelevant and incompetent; but the objection -was overruled, and the evidence admitted.

Decided 1854-09-15

Thomas, J.

¶1We cannot perceive that this evidence had any tendency to establish the guilt of the defendant.

¶2*487Under the statute of. 1837, c. 242, innholders may be licensed, but without authority to sell intoxicating liquors. The keeping of a public house is a lawful and respectable business, and the fact that a man is engaged in it has no tendency to show that he has violated any law of the Commonwealth. The innkeeper is licensed to keep his inn without authority to sell, and the presumption is that men obey the laws, and not that they violate them.

¶3Incidentally, on the trial of an indictment, the fact may appear, in what business a man is engaged. But it is obvious from the distinct offer of the evidence, persisted in after the objection of the defendant, that it was relied upon as proof of the charge contained in the indictment. For this purpose it was incompetent, and calculated to prejudice the cause of the defendant. Exceptions sustained.

/67/mass/486 · .json · Public domain