¶1 If the Bank of Redemption had brought a suit in its own name for the collection of the notes transferred nominally to Crippen, the case would present no superior equity entitling the bank to appropriate the property attached in this state exclusively to its own debt. Equity as well as comity would require the application of the property to the payment of all the creditors of the insolvents, under the insolvency laws of the state of the domicile of the bank. Kidder v. Tufts , 48 N.H. 121 ; Eddy v. Winchester ,60 N.H. 63 .
¶2 The plaintiff offers to prove that the transfer of the notes "was an absolute and bona fide sale of the same, giving to him the absolute ownership and control of the same." But it is clear that the finding of such a fact would have to be set aside as being in direct and irreconcilable conflict with the admitted facts in the case, from which the only conclusion is that the transfer of the notes was a mere cover, to enable the bank to gain a preference over other Massachusetts creditors.
¶3 The plaintiff cites Proctor v. National Bank of the Republic ,152 Mass. 223 , in support of the right to maintain his suits for the collection of the notes. But the reasons which controlled the majority of the court in that case in refusing to compel a Massachusetts creditor, who had obtained an advantage over the other creditors by his proceedings in another state, to restore the property or its value to the assignee of a Massachusetts insolvent debtor, do not exist in this case. There is no want of jurisdiction of the property or of the proper parties; and equity requires that the bank, under cover of suits in the name of a New Hampshire citizen, should not obtain an advantage over the other creditors in Massachusetts. *212
¶4 The leave given the plaintiff to defend the Strafford suits should be revoked (Levy v. Woodcock , 63 N.H. 413 ; Martin v. Wiggin, ante, p. 196) and the temporary injunction dissolved.
¶5 Bill dismissed.
¶6 ALLEN, J., did not sit: the others concurred.
¶7 The plaintiff moved for a rehearing.
Download
Copy
Embed on your site
iframe Markdown Preview card Button Hover to preview · click to copy the code
Case posture Posture BILL IN EQUITY, for an injunction restraining the defendants, Rogers, Wood, Loring Co., from prosecuting their action against Potter, White Bayley; also restraining the defendant Nutter from applying the proceeds of property attached by him as deputy sheriff in satisfaction of any judgment that may be recovered in said action; also restraining the defendants Dunn, Allen, and Bullens, assignees in insolvency in Massachusetts of the estate of Potter, White Bayley, from attempting to recover under the deed of assignment to them in the insolvency proceedings the property attached by Nutter. The bill was filed October 1, 1891.
Facts agreed. The plaintiff is a resident of this state. All the defendants except Nutter, who is a resident of this state, are residents of Massachusetts. May 25, 1891, Rogers, Wood, Loring
Co. commenced an action against the firm of Potter, White
Bayley in the supreme court for Strafford County, to recover two
promissory notes amounting to $37,500; and Nutter, as deputy sheriff, attached on the writ personal property of the debtors, consisting of shoes and shoe stock, of the value of more than $20,000, in the shoe factory of A. Nute Sons in Farmington, and summoned Nute Sons as trustees.
May 26, Potter, White Bayley, being unable to meet their maturing liabilities, made an assignment covering their property in Massachusetts and New Hampshire to Dunn, Allen, and Bullens. Rogers, Wood, Loring Co., who advised the assignment, being holders of other notes besides those sued in New Hampshire, became a party to the assignment by signing the same with other creditors, reserving, by a clause inserted in their acceptance, all their rights under their attachment.
The property attached, by agreement between the assignees, attaching creditors, and debtors, was mostly manufactured into shoes, and sold by the officer September 2 under the provisions of the statute authorizing the sale of perishable property, the net proceeds after paying the expense of manufacturing and the expenses of sale being $22,224.10, which sum is now held by the officer. August 21, 1891, proceedings in insolvency were commenced in Massachusetts against Potter, White Bayley, and later Dunn, Allen, and Bullens were appointed assignees.
Before Rogers, Wood, Loring Co. commenced their suit, they agreed verbally with Dunn and Allen to attach the property in New Hampshire for the benefit of all the creditors of Potter, White Bayley who should agree to share ratably in the assets of the debtors. July 9, Rogers, Wood, Loring Co., Potter, White Bayley, and Dunn, Allen, and Bullens agreed in writing that the expense incurred by Rogers, Wood, Loring Co. in their attachment should be paid by the assignees, and that whatever sum Rogers, Wood, Loring Co. should recover in their suit should be paid to the assignees for distribution under the terms of the assignment.
May 26, 1891, the National Bank of Redemption of Boston held two promissory notes against Potter, White Bayley, one for $4,490, which matured May 29, and one for $4,520, which matured June 25. June 1 the bank employed one Leonard, an attorney at law in Boston, to go to Concord, New Hampshire, and, if possible, sell to Crippen, the plaintiff, for $4,000 the note maturing May 29. Leonard took with him the following letter of introduction: Boston, Mass., June 1, 1891. H. J. Crippen, Concord, N.H. Dear Sir: Allow me to introduce to you Mr. W. H. Leonard of Boston. We would be very much obliged to you if you will transact the business with him which he has in hand, as he fully represents us in the premises. Very truly yours, E. A. Presbey, Cashier. Leonard also took with him the following guaranty: Whereas, the National Bank of Redemption has sold this day to H. J. Crippen of Concord, N.H., a note signed by
Potter, White Bayley to their own order and endorsed by them, dated November 26, 1890, on six months, for forty-four hundred and ninety dollars, now, therefore, in consideration of the purchase of said note by the said H. J. Crippen, the National Bank of Redemption hereby agrees to pay H. J. Crippen any deficit which the said Crippen may sustain by reason of his inability to recover the full amount of said note against said Potter, White Bayley, and also to pay said Crippen a sum equal to all his costs, charges, and expenses incurred in any attempt to collect the same, including interest. The National Bank of Redemption Boston. E. A. Presbrey, Cashier. [L. S.] June 1, 1891.
Leonard delivered to Crippen the letter of introduction, note, guaranty, and a printed copy of the case of Proctor v. National Bank of the Republic, reported in 152 Mass. 223 . Crippen consented to take the note on the terms proposed, and promised to send his check in payment of the same on the next day. Leonard returned to Boston early on June 2. Later in the day, Crippen received a letter from the bank addressed to Leonard. He did not open it, but delayed sending his check, and wrote to the bank as follows: Mr. Leonard called on me last evening and arranged for me to take the Potter, White Bayley note, $4,490. I find this morning enclosed letter for him. Not knowing whether you wish to change the arrangement, I will wait till I hear from you before doing anything about the note. The bank received the letter June 3, and sent the following telegram in reply: Letter received. No change. Send us check. On the same date the bank also sent Crippen the following letter: Your letter of 2nd inst. received and contents noted, to which I have replied by wire as follows: `Letter received. No change. Send us check.'
June 3, Crippen drew his check on the National State Capital Bank of Concord for $4,000, and the next day took the same to Boston to the Bank of Redemption and delivered it to the cashier, who offered to lend him the money if he had not money to spare. Crippen thereupon gave his promissory note for $4,000, dated June 4, payable on demand to the Bank of Redemption, and the bank discounted it. Crippen paid it March 17, 1892.
July 16, the Bank of Redemption sent the note for $4,520, maturing June 25, to Crippen, with a written guaranty similar to that of June 1, in the following letter: Enclosed I hand you note of Potter, White Bayley, dated December 22, 1890, payable six months after date, for $4,520, which we hereby sell to you for $4,000. E. A. Presbrey, Cashier. Crippen made no reply except to acknowledge the receipt of the note. July 25, the bank wrote again, and as follows: H. J. Crippen, Esq.: Will you kindly send me your check for note Potter, White Bayley, sold you 16th inst., say $4,000, and much oblige E. A. Presbrey, Cashier.
July 25, or shortly before, Crippen delivered the note to S., an
attorney of Concord, and arranged with him to take the note in Crippen's stead. S. prepared a guaranty for the bank to execute to him instead of Crippen, made his note for $4,000 payable to the bank, and delivered it and the guaranty to Crippen to be sent to the Bank of Redemption, which Crippen did in a letter of which the following is a copy: I have arranged with S. to take the note of Potter, White Bayley, and enclose a letter from him. . . . I spoke to him about this some time ago, but he had been out of town, which caused the delay. I presume it will be as satisfactory to you as if I took it. If not, let me know, and I will cancel the arrangement and take it myself.
This letter was received July 28, and the bank wrote in reply on the same day as follows: Your letter of the 25th inst. duly received. Enclosed I return the note of S., also his letter containing same, received in yours as above. I wired him to-day to take no action unless he has already done so. I do not think that this arrangement will cover the point desired. What we wish to do is to sell the note outright for cash, and I do not think it will answer to sell it to a lawyer. This is the opinion of our counsel here. I trust that no action has been taken by him. If so, please inform me what the status of the case is, and if a description of the note has been filed or given to the other side. Will you please confer with him? E. A. Presbrey, Cashier.
August 1, Crippen sent his check for $4,000 to the Bank of Redemption for the note; also his promissory note for $4,000 to be discounted and placed to the credit of Crippen, Lawrence
Co. The bank received his check in payment of the Potter, White Bayley note, discounted his note for $4,000, and sent him its written guaranty the same as that of July 16, except that it was dated July 30.
June 4, Crippen commenced a suit on the note for $4,490, and August 8 he commenced a suit on the note for $4,520. In both suits he summoned Nute Sons as trustees, and attached the property previously attached by Rogers, Wood, Loring Co., subject to their attachment. Both suits are pending in the supreme court for Merrimack county.
Crippen did not consent to the arrangements by which the shoe stock attached was manufactured into shoes and disposed of by the officer. August 7, he notified him that he objected to such an arrangement unless his suits should be settled. He has not in any way become a party to the insolvency proceedings. He learned of the failure of Potter, White Bayley prior to June 1, and the bank learned of the failure and assignment May 26, or on the day following.
The plaintiff offers to prove that the transfer of the notes by the Bank of Redemption was an absolute and bona fide sale, giving to him the absolute ownership and control of the same. Source: CourtListener