Trover, for a yoke of oxen and other cattle. Plea, the general issue, with a brief statement that the defendant, a deputy sheriff, took the cattle, August 16, 1889, on a writ against Daniel Day, and that they were Day’s property. Verdict for the plaintiff. The plaintiff, who was the first witness called, testified that in May, 1889, he sold the oxen to one Sanborn for $90, and that the defendant took them from Sanborn’s possession.
Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know
Decided 1892-12-05
How this case has been cited
Cited by 12 later decisions — most recently March 1958
11 state decisions
Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.
¶1
The request came too late. If it had been made seasonably the plaintiff would have had an opportunity to obviate the objection as to his title by further evidence, and doubtless would have done so. But however this may be, the defendant could not lie by until after the evidence, arguments, and charge to the jury were closed, and then first avail himself of ail objection that was open to him, and which in fairness he ought to have taken as soon as the evidence for the plaintiff was closed, or, at latest, when the evidence was closed on both sides.
Brown
v.
Insurance Co.,
59 N. H. 298;
Bole
v.
Thurlow,
12 Met. 157, 164;
Holden
v.
Cosgrove,
12 Gray 216, 217. And in view of the result of the trial, it is apparent that the defendant has no well founded cause of complaint by reason of the denial of his request, for however defective the proof of the plaintiff’s title may have been, the verdict establishes the fact that Day had no title at all, or, at least, only one inferior to that of the plaintiff. This of itself is a sufficient reason why a new trial should not be granted to the defendant. He has had his full day in court, and justice does not require that he should have another.
¶2
There was no legal error in refusing to permit the defendant further to inquire of the plaintiff into the source of his title to the farm and his dealings with Day in respect to it. How far justice required the cross-examination should be allowed to go in those directions was a question of fact for the trial term.
Gutterson
v.
Morse,
58 N. H. 165;
Merrill
v.
Perkins, 59
N. H. 343, 345;
Gibbs
v.
Parsons,
64 N. H. 66, 68.