Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

67 Ohio St. 3d 28

Smith v. Howard Johnson Co.

Ohio Supreme Court

Decided August 4, 1993

Ohio Supreme Court · decided 1993-08-04

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“(1) pending or probable litigation involving the plaintiff, (2) knowledge on the part of defendant that litigation exists or is probable, (3) willful destruction of evidence by defendant designed to disrupt the plaintiff's case, (4) disruption of the plaintiff's case, and (5) damages proximately caused by the defendant's acts.”

quoted by 32 later decisions, including Swekel v. City of River Rouge, Sutliff v. Cleveland Clinic Found., 91337 (1-29-2009)

“intentional or negligent spoliation of evidence and/or tortious interference with prospective civil litigation.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including Swekel v. City of River Rouge

Relies on 251 N.J. Super. 113 - Viviano v. CBS, INC.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1993-08-04

How this case has been cited

Cited by 262 later decisions — most recently May 2025 · most notably Moskovitz v. Mt. Sinai Medical Center (1994), 166 Ill. 2d 188 - Boyd v. Travelers Insurance (1995)

12 federal appellate · 7 district · 185 state decisions — followed in 22 states

10201993200020102020decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The United States District Court, Southern District of Ohio, Eastern Division, pursuant to S.CtPrac.R. XVI, has certified the following questions to us:

“1. Does Ohio recognize a claim for intentional or negligent spoliation of evidence and/or tortious interference with prospective civil litigation?
“2. If so,
“a. What are the elements of such a claim; and
“b. Does such a claim exist between the parties to the primary action (i.e., the action in which the spoliated evidence would have been used), or does it only exist against third-party spoliators?
“3. If the answer to 2(b) is that such a claim exists between the parties to the primary action, may such a claim be brought at the same time as the primary claim, or must the victim of spoliation await an adverse judgment?”

¶2We answer the three questions as follows: (1) A cause of action exists in tort for interference with or destruction of evidence; (2a) the elements of a claim for interference with or destruction of evidence are (1) pending or probable litigation involving the plaintiff, (2) knowledge on the part of defendant that litigation exists or is probable, (3) willful destruction of evidence by defendant designed to disrupt the plaintiffs case, (4) disruption of the plaintiffs case, and (5) damages proximately caused by the defendant’s acts; (2b) such a claim should be recognized between the parties to the primary action and against third parties; and (3) such a claim may be brought at the same time as the primary action. See Viviano v. CBS, Inc. (1991), 251 N.J.Super. 113, 126, 597 A.2d 543, 550.

Moyer, C.J., A.W. Sweeney, Douglas, Deshler, Resnick, F.E. Sweeney and Pfeifer, JJ., concur.Dana A. Deshler, J., of the Tenth Appellate District, sitting for Wright, J.
/67/ohiost3d/28 · .json · Public domain