Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

67 Vt. 477

State v. Carroll

Supreme Court of Vermont

Decided January 15, 1895

Supreme Court of Vermont · decided 1895-01-15

Indictment for an assault with intent to commit rape. Plea, not guilty. Trial by jury at the December term, 1894, Lamoille county, Start, J., presiding. Verdict, guilty. The respondent excepts. The indictment was for a criminal assault upon a female ■child four and one-half years old. She was not permitted to testify, for the reason that she did not understand the nature of an oath. The testimony of the prosecution tended to show that the assault was committed in a barn.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently February 1971

1 state decisions

Relies on State v. Niles

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1895-01-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

TAFT, J.

¶1I. It was held in State v. Niles, 47 Vt. 82, that it is competent to prove that the person upon whom a rape is alleged to have been committed made a complaint, and that an individual, the complainant naming him, was charged by her with its commission. The rule is the same-in a prosecution for an attempt. In some jurisdictions the details of the complaint may-be given., but in this state the prosecution has never been permitted to go further than to-prove that the person complained that an assault had been made, and that a certain person made it. We are not inclined to extend the rule. It was a departure from it, and therefore error, when the witness was allowed to state any of the details of the complaint, such as the exact location of the alleged assault, that it was committed upon a pile of corn stalks, and in a certain corner of the barn.

¶2II. As we are not fully agreed upon the question raised by the exception to the charge, and as the same question-will not necessarily arise upon another trial, we do not consider it.

¶3The first exceflion is sustained. Judgment reversed^ verdict set aside, and cause remanded for a new trial.

/67/vt/477 · .json · Public domain