Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

68 Conn. 311

State v. Royce

Supreme Court of Connecticut

Decided November 5, 1896

Supreme Court of Connecticut · decided 1896-11-05

<p>Seetion 3916 of the General Statutes requires the secretary or cashier of certain corporations to deliver annually to the comptroller a sworn list of its non-resident stockholders, together with the number and market value of their shares, and to pay to the State one per cent of such value; it also provides that if the cashier or secretary neglects to comply with the statute, he shall forfeit $100 dollars to the State, in addition to the one per cent required to be paid. Section 3930 makes these returns and valuations subject to final revision by the board of equalization, upon whose valuation the tax of one per cent is to be computed; while § 3942 declares that the failure of such board to perform its duties, shall not affect suits by the State for the recovery of any sum in the nature of a tax, or for the penalty for its non-payment. In an action against the secretary of a corporation to recover one per cent upon the difference between the value of the shares as returned by him and their actual market value as claimed by the plaintiff, it was held upon demurrer to the complaint:—</p> <p>1. That in the enactment of § 3942 and the other sections of chapter 244 of the General Statutes, it was evidently the intention of the legislature that the corporation itself would be the real tax debtor, and the defendant in any action therein authorized for the recovery of an unpaid tax.</p> <p>2. That the failure of the board of equalization to revise the defendant’s valuation did not affect in any way the question of his liability for the prescribed forfeiture.</p> <p>3. That § 3916 imposed no liability for a tax upon the secretary of a corporation, and inasmuch as the plaintiff expressly disclaimed any right to recover the amount demanded by way of forfeiture, the demurrer was properly overruled.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently June 1898

1 state decisions

Relies on State v. New York, New Haven & Hartford Railroad

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

No error · Decided 1896-11-05

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Andrews, C. J.

¶1Section 3942 of the General Statutes provides that no suit brought by the State to recover a tax from any person or corporation shall be barred or defeated by any omission to act by the board of equalization. Such a construction has been put on this section that it seems to authorize an action by the State for any unpaid tax. State v. N. Y., N. H. & H. R. R., 60 Conn. 326, 335; Coite v. Society for Savings, 32 id. 171; Coite v. Conn. Mut. Life Ins. Co., 36 id. 512; Nichols v. N. H. & N. Co., 42 id. 103; State v. Housatonic R. R., 48 id. 42. Whether or not a suit could be maintained against the Hartford Fire Insurance Company for the portion of the tax against it, claimed in this action to be unpaid, is a question not arising in this case. The several cases which we have cited were all brought against the corporation itself; although in each case the corporation had, presumably, a cashier or secretary who had failed in each case to pay the tax sued for. An examination of the section named, as well as of the other sections of the chapter in which it is included, indicates that the legislature supposed the corporation itself would be the defendant against which any action for an unpaid tax, authorized by that statute, would be brought. The corporation is the real tax debtor.

¶2The complaint in the present action counts upon the provisions Of title 76 of the General Statutes, and especially on § 3916 (one of the sections included in that title), which reads as follows: “The cashier or secretary of each corporation whose stock is liable to taxation and not otherwise taxed by the provisions of this title, shall on the first day of October, annually, or within ten days thereafter, deliver to the comp*316troller a sworn list of all its stockholders, residing without this State on said day, and the number and market value of the shares of stock therein, then belonging to each; and shall on or before the twentieth day of October, annually, pay to the State one per cent, of such value; and if any such cashier or secretary shall neglect- to comply with the provisions of this section he shall forfeit to the State one hundred dollars, in addition to said one per. cent, so required to be paid.” Another section, 3865 in the same title, constitutes a board of equalization; and § 3930 provides that said board shall hold meetings within certain specified days, “ to examine and correct” the returns made by such cashier or secretary “and the valuations required thereon,” and then enacts that the statement as corrected or made out by the said board shall be returned to the said cashier or secretary, “ and the valuation of the several items of money, estate, amount and number contained in such statement, shall be final, and the sums required shall be paid according to it.”

¶3The complaint is recited in the statement of the case. It appears therefrom that the defendant, in each of the years 1891 and 1892, did all those things which, in the absence of any action by the board of equalization, the section first mentioned—3916 of the General Statutes—made it his duty to do, in respect to the stock of the Hartford Fire Insurance Company; and it also appears that the board of equalization, in each of the years, failed and omitted to take any action on the sworn lists so made out and returned to the comptroller by the defendant. But such omission by the board in nowise increases or in any way affects the forfeiture to which the defendant may be liable. Prima facie then, the defendant has fully performed all those acts and things which that section of the statute commanded him to do, and as a consequence he cannot be subjected to anjr forfeiture.

¶4There are other averments in the complaint, to the effect that the market value of the shares as returned by the defendant was erroneous,—being stated at $285 per share when it ought to have been stated at $340—-and that by reason of that error the State received a very much less sum from the de*317fendant than it ought to have received. It is this difference which the State seeks to recover in this suit. Counsel for the State in their brief and in their oral argument disclaim any right to recover the amount of the difference as a forfeiture ; they claim to recover it as the unpaid balance of a tax. It is not pretended, much less is it alleged, that the defendant can be required to pay this amount on the ground that there is any unpaid tax standing against him. There is no such tax. He can be required to pay the amount, if at all, only on behalf of the corporation whose servant he is, and whose debt the tax is.

¶5The Hartford Fire Insurance Company is a corporation created by the legislature of this State. It would doubtless be in the power of the legislature to impose a tax on that corporation, and to make its secretary liable to a suit in favor of the State if that tax was not paid; but such a liability on the part of a corporation could never exist unless some statute clearly declared it. There is no averment in the complaint that any such liability of the defendant exists; nor is there any statute, so far as has been pointed out to us, which would justify the averment if made. Section 3916 creates no liability against any secretary of a corporation, except in the form of a forfeiture; and it is expressly conceded that the defendant is not liable to any forfeiture. It seems to us that section 3942 does not create any liability personally against him. No other sections have been cited.

¶6There is no error.

¶7In this opinion the other judges concurred.

/68/conn/311 · .json · Public domain