Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

68 N.H. 264

38 A 1049

Perkins v. Perkins

Supreme Court of New Hampshire

Decided June 5, 1895

Supreme Court of New Hampshire · decided 1895-06-05

Bill in Equity, filed December 16, 1892, by Langdon M. Perkins, administrator of the estate of Mary A. Perkins, against Elizabeth A. Perkins and the Portsmouth Savings Bank. Facts found by the court. Mary A. Perkins died February 13,1888, and the plaintiff' was appointed administrator of her estate, January 14, 1892. At the time of her death she was the owner of a deposit in the Portsmouth Savings Bank and of a sum of money.

Relies on Morse v. Whitcher · Chandler v. Davis · Hoit v. Russell

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1895-06-05

How this case has been cited

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently April 1940

3 state decisions

10189519001910192019301940decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Blodgett, J.

¶1 The offer of the defendant to testify to conversations and transactions between her deceased husband and the plaintiff’s intestate was alike properly rejected as a matter of law and of discretion, under the statutory provisions excluding the testimony of the adverse party in respect to facts which ■occurred in the lifetime of the deceased, where an administrator or executor is a party of record or a party in interest, unless the administrator or executor elects so to testify, or it clearly appears to the court that injustice may be done without the testimony of the other party. P. S., c. 224, ss. 16-18; Chandler v. Davis, 47 N. H. 462, 465; Harvey v. Hilliard, 47 N. H. 551, 553; True v. Shepard, 51 N. H. 501, 602; Hoit v. Russell, 56 N. H. 559, 563; Drew v. McDaniel, 60 N. H. 480, 482; Tack v. Nelson, 62 N. H. 469, 471, 472; English v. Porter, 63 N. H. 206, 215. In brief, there is nothing in the reported facts to take the case out of the genera] rule that ordinarily “ the safe guide and the decisive test is found in the inquiry whether the deceased, if alive, could testify to the same matters.”

¶2 The suit being against the defendant in her private capacity, she cannot interpose the statutory limitation of three years *266 (P. S., c. 191, s. 4) in bar of its maintenance; nor could she if it were against her in her official capacity as executrix of her deceased husband’s will, the suit having been brought “ within two years after tbe original grant of administration ” upon the estate of the plaintiff’s intestate, in whose favor the right of action against the husband existed at the time of her death, Ib., s. 6; Brewster v. Brewster, 52 N. H. 52, 59; Morse v. Whitcher, 64 N. H. 591, 592.

¶3 Exceptions overruled.

Wallace, J., did not sit: the others concurred.
/68/nh/264 · .json · Public domain