Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

69 Ill. 257

Seibel v. Vaugham

Illinois Supreme Court

Decided September 15, 1873

Illinois Supreme Court · decided 1873-09-15

Edwin S. Leland, Judge, presiding. This was an action of assumpsit, brought by James H. Vaughan against Jacob Seibel, upon a promissory note given by the defendant, for §464, payable to J. B. Drake, and indorsed in blank by the payee.

Relies on Snell v. Trustees of the Society of the Methodist Episcopal Church · Smith v. Gillett · Harvey v. Smith

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1873-09-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently June 1925

3 state decisions

10187318801890190019101920decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Mr. Justice Scott

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court:

¶2The points upon which appellant relies for a reversal of the judgment are:

¶31st. The court erred in admitting improper evidence.

¶42d. The court erred in giving and refusing instructions.

¶53d. The verdict is contrary to the law and the evidence.

¶6The action was upon a promissory note, and one issue made by the complicated pleadings in the case was, there was a failure of consideration. The evidence as to the utility of the invention for which the note was given, which was admitted over the objections of appellant, seems to us to have been pertinent to the issue. But if the court erred in that regard, the evidence was of that character it could do no harm, and certainly appellant was not prejudiced by it. It was not of enough importance to be made the ground of a reversal of the judgment.

¶7It is insisted that the court erred in giving the second instruction for appellee. By it the jury, in substance, were told that, if appellant executed the note in controversy with a material portion written only in pencil, subject to be easily erased so as to leave no appearance of alteration on the face of the note, when, by ordinary care and prudence, he could have guarded against erasures, he was guilty of negligence, and could not defeat its collection in the hands of an innocent holder, who took it before maturity, without notice of any alteration.

¶8While it is true there are some slightly inaccurate expressions to be found in the instruction, nevertheless it states a correct principle of law, and is fully sustained by the adjudged cases in this court. Harvey v. Smith, 55 Ill. 224; Leech v. Nichols, ib. 273.

¶9The only serious question that could arise in the case is on the third point, viz: the verdict is contrary to the law and the evidence. But it does not appear there was any motion for a new trial. Such a motion, and exceptions to the decision of the court, must be preserved in the bill of exceptions, otherwise it can not be considered in this court. Snell v. Trustees M. E. Church, 58 Ill. 290.

¶10It may now be regarded as the settled practice in this State, that a judgment will not be reversed for insufficiency of evidence if a motion for a new trial was not made in the court below. Barnes v. Barber, 1 Gilman, 401; Smith v. Gillett, 50 Ill. 290.

¶11The alleged motion for a new trial is not preserved in the bill of exceptions, as required by the practice in this court, and no exception whatever was taken to the decision of the court. We can not, therefore, consider the point made, whether the evidence sustains the verdict.

¶12Perceiving no error in the record, the judgment is affirmed.

¶13Judgment affirmed.

/69/ill/257 · .json · Public domain