Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

69 Ill. App. 419

Faith v. Taylor

Appellate Court of Illinois

Decided February 25, 1897

Appellate Court of Illinois · decided 1897-02-25

<p>Trespass oil the Case, for impairment of a lien. Appeal from the Circuit Court of Macon County; the Hon. Edward P. Vail, Judge, presiding.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently October 1898

1 state decisions

Relies on Finney v. Harding

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Reversed and remanded · Decided 1897-02-25

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Mr. Justice Wall

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court.

¶2This was an action on the case, in which the plaintiff alleged that, being the owner of certain land, he leased the same to one Lili for certain rent to be paid in money; that the said Lili raised a quantity of corn on the land upon which the plaintiff had a lien for his rent, and that while said lien was subsisting, the rent being due and unpaid, said Lili sold the corn to defendant, who well knew that Lili was the tenant of the plaintiff, and that the corn was raised upon the demised premises; that defendant converted the corn to his own use, and thereby plaintiff was deprived of his lien, wherefore he sought to recover the value of so much thereof as would be necessary to pay the rent.

¶3The defendant pleaded the general issue, and upon trial by jury there was a verdict for $254.80, upon which judgment was rendered. The defendant has appealed.

¶4The evidence sufficiently established the allegations of the declaration as to the tenancy, and the knowledge thereof by the defendant at the time of the purchase, but the defense relied upon was that the plaintiff, after his rent was due, authorized the tenant to sell the corn, and that defendant knew that fact when he bought. Is this a defense ? In the case of Finney v. Harding, 136 Ill. 573, the Supreme Court held, that under our statute the landlord having no right of property in the crop raised by the tenant, and no right of possession by virtue of his mere lien, can maintain no action against the purchaser except for a fraudulent act intended to impair the lien. The gist of the right of recovery is declared to be the wrongful or tortious act of defendant, or the omission of some legal duty, in consequence of which injury has resulted to the plaintiff.

¶5In that case, for the first time, the question was directly presented whether an innocent purchaser without notice was liable to the landlord, and it was answered in the negative.

¶6In view of the doctrine thus announced, which is well supported by the authorities cited, it seems very clear that where the landlord authorizes the tenant to sell and receive the proceeds, and where the purchaser is aware of the fact, there can be no recovery.

¶7In such case there is no fraudulent act by the purchaser calculated to impair the landlord’s security—nothing wrongful or tortious. When the landlord permits the tenant to sell, he permits him to receive the purchase money. Though the purchaser knows of the landlord’s lien, yet he knows also that the tenant is selling with such permission, and in paying the money to him he is doing no more than the landlord has authorized. To allow the landlord to hold him, under such circumstances, would be unjust and inequitable. The judgment will be reversed and the cause remanded.

/69/illapp/419 · .json · Public domain