Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

69 Ill. App. 654

Matthei v. Wooley

Appellate Court of Illinois

Decided April 15, 1897

Appellate Court of Illinois · decided 1897-04-15

<p>1. Medical Practice—Who are Physicians.—A person who treats, operates on, or prescribes for any physical ailment must be regarded as practicing medicine, within the meaning of chapter 91, R; S., entitled “ Medicine and Surgery.”</p> <p>2. Same— Persons Holding Themselves out as Doctors.—If by treating, operating on, or prescribing for physical ailments, a person holds himself out as a doctor to persons employing him, and they believe him to be a doctor, he will be chargeable as such.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently March 1988

1 state decisions

Relies on McNevins v. Lowe

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Affirmed · Decided 1897-04-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Mr. Justice Gary

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court.

¶2There was a conflict of evidence on the trial of this case; abundance on either side to win on.

¶3The jury settled that conflict in favor of the appellee, and any review of it would serve only to prove that the conclusion of the jury can not be set aside.

¶4The appellee sued the appellant for the ill consequences to the appellee by the malpractice of the appellant as a physician and surgeon.

¶5The appellant is a druggist. According to the evidence on the part of the appellee, he thought the appellant was also a doctor, and went to him with a hurt finger, which the appellant treated wrongly for ten days, the result of which was inability for a long time to work, and finally amputation of the finger.

¶6If the appellant did in fact “ treat, operate on, or prescribe for any physical ailment of” the appellee, the statute regards him as “ practicing medicine,” within the meaning of Gh. 91, R. S.

¶7If by so doing he held himself out to the appellee as a doctor, and the appellee believed the appellant to be a doctor, then he is chargeable in that character. McNevins v. Lowe, 40 Ill. 209.

¶8The only question argued is the sufficiency of the evidence, and we can only affirm the judgment, which is done.

¶9Mr. Justice Waterman dissents.

/69/illapp/654 · .json · Public domain