Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

69 N.H. 200

42 A 900

Munroe v. St. Germain

Supreme Court of New Hampshire

Decided June 5, 1897

Supreme Court of New Hampshire · decided 1897-06-05

Trover, for a stock of goods. Facts found by a referee. August 15, 1895, Cavanaugh & O’Leary sold and delivered the stock of goods to the plaintiff in settlement of their indebtedness to him. Four days later, the defendant, a deputy sheriff, attached the goods as their property upon a writ in favor of one of their creditors and subsequently sold them.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently June 1948

1 state decisions

Relies on Stevens v. Morse · Jones v. Bryant · Hill v. Pine River Bank

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1897-06-05

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Pike, J.

¶1 Assuming that the sale to the plaintiff was fraudulent as to creditors of Cavanaugh & O’Leary, and that the goods were lawfully attached and sold upon the writ, the sheriff had no power over the proceeds of the sale except to hold them for application according to law. P. 8., c. 220, s. 42. The plaintiff’s title was good as against Cavanaugh & O’Leary, and good as against every one else except attaching creditors. Jones v. Bryant, 13 N. H. 53; Hill v. Bank, 45 N. H. 300, 309; Stevens v. Morse, 47 N. H. 532, 535. The failure to return the writ to court dissolved the attachment, and the sheriff became bound to deliver the proceeds of the sale to the .plaintiff. P. S., c. 220, s. 36. Pie had no authority to- pay it to the attaching creditor except upon a levy. No execution has been or can now be had, and the defendant’s payment without judgment and levy was unauthorized and is no answer to the present suit.

¶2*201 Under similar circumstances, it has been held in Massachusetts that a sheriff cannot justify under his attachment unless he returns his writ to court. Wilder v. Holden, 24 Pick. 8, 12; Rass v. Butterfield, 6 Cush. 242; Williams v. Babbitt, 14 Gray 141.

¶3 Exception overruled.

Parsons, J., did not sit: the others concurred.
/69/nh/200 · .json · Public domain