¶1delivered the opinion of the court.
¶2The plaintiff is the owner of certain fractional subdivisions of sections 27 and 28, township 26 south, range 31 east of the "Willamette meridian, in Harney County, bounded on the north by the meander line of Malheur Lake, a non-navigable body of water, fed by Silvies River on the north and Blitzen River on the south, and finding its outlet through a channel which its waters have forced into Harney Lake. The land in dispute is on the lake side of this meander line, and lies in front of the lots owned by the plaintiff, although other land of a similar nature intervenes between them and the premises he would recover. The plaintiff claims these lands as accretions to his lots, which he purchased and holds under "a patent from the United States government. His contention is that, his lands being bounded by the meander line of the lake, as evidenced by the official plats, he takes by *43operation of law, as an accretion, all land beyond the line and uncovered by the recession of the lake. The defendants maintain that the meander line as laid upon the ground, and forming on the maps of the survey the north boundary of the lots owned by the plaintiff, did not truly represent the meander of the lake at the time it was surveyed, and that he is privileged to show that fact, with the result that plaintiff cannot take any land north of the actual meander line as thus traced, and is forbidden to advance his boundary with the retreating waters.
¶3Another question involved is based upon plaintiff’s objections to sundry instructions given by the court to the jury. The meander line in question was surveyed by a deputy United States surveyor in 1895. Among other things the court charged the jury thus:
“I instruct you, gentlemen, that if you find a meander line or some line of survey was run along the northern boundary of the lands last described [meaning the lots owned by plaintiff] that is not conclusive evidence of the existence of a lake at that point. You will therefore weigh and consider all of the evidence in this case, and the facts, the conclusion, to be deduced from the whole evidence is to determine whether in fact there was a lake north of and adjoining plaintiff’s land described in his patent,-and if there was not such lake at the time such meander line was run, to wit, in the year 1895, you will find for the defendants; that is to say, I instruct you that before you can find for the plaintiff, you must be satisfied from a preponderance of the evidence that during the year in which such meander line was run there was a lake immediately north of and adjoining the land described in plaintiff’s patent as belonging to him, but if you believe from the evidence that there was a swamp or marsh instead of a lake, immediately north of and adjoining said lands, then you will find for the defendants. In other words, it is a fact for you to *44determine whether there was a lake. If there was such lake at the meander line, the plaintiff should recover, if the land uncovered by the recession of the lake, which said recession you find to have been natural and gradual, be not of such considerable area or amount as would increase his holdings and possessions under his patent to such an extent as would be unreasonable and beyond the possible intention of the government in the execution of said patent. ’ ’
¶4Again, after the jury had retired and been in deliberation for some time, they returned and asked the court for further instructions respecting the amount of land the plaintiff might recover.
¶5Whereupon the court gave the following instruction:
“With reference to the amount of land that the plaintiff — a plaintiff in proceedings of this kind might claim by virtue of the fact that his holdings are separated from the lake by means of a meander line, I instruct you that a meander line should mark the shore line of abutting property, if such line is properly surveyed. If it does not mark such line practically, it is not a true meander line, and should be disregarded. It is not necessary that this line shall coincide with the edge of the lake by following the true curvature of the shore line. It may consist of broken straight lines, and is to control if it is so located as not to leave a considerable body of land between the said meander line and the water’s edge when the lake is at its usual or ordinary state. So in this case, if the meander line of 1895 fairly marks the shore line of the lake at that time, it would be controlling here, and the plaintiff must recover, unless the recession of the waters from the original shore line of the lake as shown by that survey has been so great as to add a very considerable quantity of land, amounting to as much or more land as that described in the patent which the plaintiff obtained from the government, in which latter case the meander line must be regarded *45as Ms north boundary, and he cannot recover here in such case.”
¶6
¶7
¶8
¶9
¶10Concerning this very lake this court, speaking by Mr. Justice Wolverton, in French Livestock Co. v. Springer, 35 Or. 312 (58 Pac. 102), said: “It is a question of no moment to the parties in the present con*47troversy whether the shore or upland owner takes to the water’s edge or to the center of a non-navigable lake, or what title, if any, has been acquired by reason of such ownership, without reservation in the muniments of the title to the land under the water of the lake, as, in any event, the owner is entitled to all land between the original line and the water’s edge, which shall have become bare by accretion or a gradual and imperceptible recession of the water, not extending beyond the center of the lake.” In good reas'on there can be no difference in principle between non-navigable lakes and non-navigable rivers respecting recessions and accretions, especially where, as in this instance, both alike rise and fall in the wet and dry seasons. It is said in a work on Elementary Physical Geography by William Morris Davis: “Lakes may be generally taken to indicate a useful drainage system. In time they will be destroyed; partly by filling with the waste that is brought by the inflowing streams, partly by the deepening of the outlet valley. Lakes should therefore be regarded as only temporary features in the long life of the river system to which they belong. The rivers may remain long after the lakes disappear.” It is laid down in Hardin v. Jordan, 140 U. S. 371 (35 L. Ed. 428, 11 Sup. Ct. Rep. 808, 838), that “grants by the United States of its public lands bounded on streams and other waters, made without reservation or restriction, are to be construed as to their effect according to the laws of the state in which the lands he. It depends upon thé laws of each state to what extent the prerogative of the state to lands under water shall extend. ’ ’ At the argument the case of Scott v. Lattig, 227 U. S. 229 (57 L. Ed. 490, 33 Sup. Ct. Rep. 242, 44 L. R. A. (N. S.) 107), was cited as modifying the rule laid down in Hardin v. Jordan, 140 U. S. 371 (35 L. Ed. 428, 11 Sup. Ct. Rep. 808), but the *48two cases are unlike in this: That the Hardin-Jordan case relates to a non-navigable lake, while the other ease has to do with a fixed and well-defined island in a navigable river. The case at bar is more like Whitaker v. McBride, 197 U. S. 510 (49 L. Ed. 857, 25 Sup. Ct. Rep. 530), in which the Supreme Court of the United States decided that, “by the law of Nebraska … the riparian proprietors. are the owners of the bed of a stream to the center of the channel; that the government as original proprietor has the right to survey and sell any lands, including islands in a river or other body of water; that if it omits to survey an island in a stream, and refuses, when its attention is called to the matter, to make any survey thereof, no citizen can overrule the action of the department, assume that the island ought to have been surveyed., and proceed to occupy it for the purposes of homestead or preemption entry. In such a case the rights of riparian proprietors are to be preferred to the claims of the settler.” Section 878, L. O. L., declares: “The following are the rules for construing the descriptive part of a conveyance of real property, when the construction is doubtful, and there are no other sufficient circumstances to determine it: * # (4) When a road or stream of water not navigable is the boundary, the rights of the grantor to the middle of the road, or the thread of the stream, are included in the conveyance, except where the road or bed of the stream is held under another title. ’ ’ In Micelli v. Andrus, 61 Or. 78, (120 Pac. 737), Mr. Justice Moore said:
“The United States originally owned the bed of each unnavigable river, and, when any land bordering thereon is granted by the general government or its successors in title, by describing a border line as running to a bank of the stream and thence with its meanders, giving them, the boundary of the premises *49conveyed, unless restricted by express words, extends by tbe overwhelming preponderance of judicial utterance to tbe center of the river. ’ ’
¶11Until legislation of tbe state has changed its policy on this point, we must bold that tbe riparian owner of land granted by tbe general government abutting upon a correctly established meander line is at least entitled to follow tbe water of tbe lake or river thus meandered, no matter bow far it may recede. Tbe Circuit Court was in error when it undertook to limit tbe plaintiff in tbe amount of bis accretion resulting from tbe retreat of tbe water in front of bis original holdings.
¶12Tbe judgment of tbe Circuit Court is reversed and tbe cause remanded for further proceedings.
¶13Reversed and Remanded.