Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

695 So. 2d 834

Docket No. 96-04138.

Zelinski v. State

Richard Burns ZELINSKI, Appellant, v. STATE of Florida, Appellee.

District Court of Appeal of Florida · decided 1997-06-18

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently March 2008

5 state decisions

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“who had left a convenience store lacked a well-founded suspicion that defendant or other occupants of the vehicle parked on the back of the property with its lights off were involved in criminal activity). After the motion was denied, Appellant pled no contest to the charges while reserving the right to appeal the denial of his motion to suppress, which was deemed dispositive. He was placed on one year of probation. Although the trial court's”

quoted by 1 later decision, including 975 So. 2d 1163 - Cox v. State

“Whether characterized as a request or an order, we conclude that Deputy Wilmouth's direction for Popple to exit his vehicle constituted a show of authority which restrained Popple's freedom of movement because a reasonable person under the circumstances would believe that he should comply.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including 761 So. 2d 383 - Thomasset v. State

Relies on 626 So. 2d 185 - Popple v. State · 592 So. 2d 1206 - Smith v. State

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1997-06-18

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1*835 Joseph A. Eustace, Jr. of Anthony J. LaSpada, P.A., Tampa, for Appellant.

¶2Robert A. Butterworth, Attorney General, Tallahassee, and Tonja R. Vickers, Assistant Attorney General, Tampa, for Appellee.

¶3PARKER, Judge.

¶4Richard Burns Zelinski appeals the trial court's order denying his dispositive motion to suppress evidence. We reverse.

¶5The state charged Zelinski with possession of marijuana and resisting arrest without violence. At the motion to suppress hearing, Officer Cravens testified that he was dispatched to a convenience store/gas station-type business in Plant City because of a reported suspicious person. Upon arrival, Officer Cravens, in uniform, met with the owner of the business, Mr. Siddiqui, who stated that the suspicious person had left. However, Mr. Siddiqui expressed concern over a vehicle that was parked toward the back of the property with its lights off. The vehicle was occupied by several people.

¶6Upon entering the store, Officer Cravens passed Zelinski who was leaving the store. Mr. Siddiqui told Officer Cravens that Zelinski was one of the occupants of the vehicle and that he was trying to buy beer. Officer Cravens believed that Zelinski looked "a little young" to be purchasing beer.

¶7As he left the store, Officer Cravens noticed that Zelinski was a passenger in the front seat of a vehicle which was departing from the store. The vehicle eventually stopped near the gasoline pumps. The reason the vehicle stopped is disputed. Officer Cravens testified that he spoke to the vehicle occupants without ordering the vehicle to stop. Mr. Siddiqui described Officer Cravens as very active, running toward the vehicle in an aggressive manner, saying "[h]old on" or "[s]top." Zelinski testified that Officer Cravens ran toward the moving vehicle waving his hand and telling the occupants to stop.

¶8Both Officer Cravens and Zelinski testified that Officer Cravens asked Zelinski to step out of the vehicle. Zelinski testified that he did not feel free to leave. Officer Cravens then obtained Zelinski's identification, ran a check for warrants, and determined there was an outstanding warrant for Zelinski. Officer Cravens arrested Zelinski based on the warrant. Thereafter, Officer Cravens searched Zelinski's person and discovered marijuana.

¶9In Zelinski's motion to suppress, he alleged that the stop was illegal. The trial court denied Zelinski's motion to suppress, finding that the confrontation between Zelinski and Officer Cravens was a "consensual encounter," rather than a seizure. Zelinski entered a plea of no contest reserving his right to appeal the denial of his motion to suppress. The parties stipulated that the motion to suppress was dispositive of the case, and the trial court so found.

¶10It is not necessary to address the trial court's finding that the initial confrontation between Officer Cravens and Zelinski *836 was a consensual encounter. We conclude that if there was a consensual encounter, it became an investigatory stop at the point where Officer Cravens asked Zelinski to step out of the vehicle. Popple v. State, 626 So.2d 185 (Fla.1993). In Popple, the supreme court stated:

Whether characterized as a request or an order, we conclude that Deputy Wilmoth's direction for Popple to exit his vehicle constituted a show of authority which restrained Popple's freedom of movement because a reasonable person under the circumstances would believe that he should comply.
Therefore, we hold that for Fourth Amendment purposes Popple did not consent to exiting his vehicle, but rather was seized by virtue of submitting to Deputy Wilmoth's show of authority. Because Deputy Wilmoth did not have the reasonable suspicion necessary to authorize an investigatory stop, the initial detention was illegal and the resulting acquisition of the cocaine and drug paraphernalia was the fruit of an unconstitutional seizure.

¶11Id. at 188 (footnote omitted; citations omitted). In order to justify a stop under the Fourth Amendment, there must be a well-founded, articulable suspicion that the person has committed, is committing, or is about to commit a crime. A mere or bare suspicion will not suffice. Id. at 186; Smith v. State, 592 So.2d 1206, 1207 (Fla. 2d DCA 1992).

¶12Officer Cravens did not have the requisite, well-founded suspicion that Zelinski or the automobile's other occupants had committed or were about to commit a crime. Furthermore, the stop was not made pursuant to a valid traffic stop. Therefore, the marijuana obtained was the fruit of an unlawful seizure. Accordingly, we reverse the trial court's order denying the motion to suppress and remand this case to the trial court to grant the motion to suppress.

¶13FRANK, A.C.J., and LAZZARA, J., concur.

/695/so2d/834 · .json · Public domain