Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

7 Ark. 122

Edwalds v. State

Supreme Court of Arkansas

Decided July 15, 1851

Supreme Court of Arkansas · decided 1851-07-15

John R. Edwards was convicted of manslaughter, in the Poin-sett Circuit Court, at the April term, 1850, and sentenced to imprisonment in the Penitentiary, and to pay the costs of the prosecution, which were taxed at $305 32£1 Afterwards, the following pardon was granted to him by the Governor: The State of Arkansas— To all to whom these presents shall come— GREETING : Whereas, At the late term of the Circuit Court,for the county of Poinsett, John R. Edwards was convicted,…

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1851-07-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 8 later decisions — most recently March 1932

8 state decisions

40185118601870188018901900191019201930decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Mr. Justice Scott

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court.

¶2The only question presented is whether or not the legal effect of the pardon was to discharge the judgment for costs.

¶3The case of Amour Muni, Ex Parie, (5 Eng. 284,) cited by the appellant’s counsel does not sustain the position contended for by him. That was a case where a pardon was construed; but this is as to the legal effect of a pardon in general terms involving no question of construction.

¶4All that is said of the legal effect of a pardon in the case cited is that “ Its legal effect is to restore the convict at once to the rights of liberty and citizenship,” and Lilly's Mr. 270, is there cited to show that its effects are not only to discharge the punishment, but also to wipe out the guilt of the offence. To use the language of that author, “It pardons culpor so clearly that, in the eye of the law, the offender is as innocent as if he never had committed the offence.” Not that its effect relates back to a moment anterior to the conviction and removes every thing that would be inconsistent with its ever having existed — as to annul the second marriage of the convicts wife, or the sale of his property made' by persons appointed to administer his estate, or to divest the title of his heirs of the interest acquired in his estate in consequence of his civil death. (Maker of Doming, 10 John. 232. S. C. Ib. 488) — but that it creates new legal capacities for him and removes the stain of guilt, as completely as if he had never committed the offence. And by parity of reason it cannot release him from like intervening obligations. In a word, it does not continue him in a state of innocence for all purposes, but restores him to that state from the date of the delivery of his pardon.

¶5Nor did the King’s pardon in England remove every effect of a conviction. On the contrary, in every case where the disability was a part of the judgment itself, nothing short of a general pardon by act of Parliament would remove it, although it was otherwise when the disability was only consequential. {Rex. v. Wee-den, et al: 3 Salk• 264.)

¶6Costs are neither “fines” nor “forfeitures,” nor are they imposed by way of punishment, or as amercement at common law, but by way of sequence to every judgment whether in a civil or criminal case, as a matter of common justice to the party complainant, witnesses and officers of court, although the judgment is in favor of the complainant alone. Costs then partaking, in no respect, of the nature, either of punishment or of guilt, are without the sphere of the legitimate legal operation of a pardon, however general in its terms. And this view is sustained in principle by a much stronger case reported in 2 Bay. R. 565, (Rowe v. State,) where it was held that a pardon from the Government did not discharge the moiety of a fine which goes to the informer.

¶7There is uo error in the record. Let the judgment of the court below be affirmed.

/7/ark/122 · .json · Public domain